Joe Budden is biased. And wrote a love song to Em. Slaughtermouse?
Had do you know how analytical any of them are? Considering how analytical they are in their writing styles and writing skills, I doubt any of you posters have a superior ability to do so themselves.
Its more or less an Em hate circle jerk and dissing someone who accomplished more for Hip Hop than you posting is supposed to mean something to BDK?
Bob Costas had won numerous awards as being a sports analyst. How high do you place his opinion?
It's not the opinion itself all the time. It's the evidence they are using, the validity of the examples, the ability to point out something that others haven't previously, how consistent they are etc.
When Game says something like "I feel MGK beat Eminem because nobody expected him to go at Em so hard" I think it's stupid because he's comparing MGK's work with an expectation that was formed based on MGK's previous work. He was not comparing the records that Em and MGK made to one another...which is the actual relevant comparison.
when Charlatan da fraud said he didn't respect Wayne saying he'd kidnap Beyonce because it was obviously not realistic Envy immediately pointed out that Jay talks about murking people in a way he clearly won't all the time.
When Budden said HE DIDN'T EVEN LISTEN TO REVIVAL it immediately destroys any credibility he had because you don't have enough information to accurately judge music you haven't listened to.
If you can explain and understand things like flow, lyrics, pocket, how good a beat is, how well someone matches the beat, stays on beat, delivery, etc it means more than just saying you like or don't like something.