As a 2-State Solution Loses Steam, a 1-State Plan Gains Traction in Israel/Palestine

invalid

Veteran
Joined
Feb 21, 2015
Messages
20,404
Reputation
7,166
Daps
82,395


The facts are the facts.
Israel was ready for a two-state solution.
Arab nations wouldn't entertain it and declared war on Israel.
Israel staved off the Arab nations and came out of the war with more land.

But beside all that, the British mandate gave Israel ownership of the land. That's fact.
Of which the British received from the Ottoman empire who previously controlled the region. Which is also fact.

The idea of a self-autonomous, self-ruling Palestine with a distinct identity and culture did not exist.
So-called Palestinians were just inhabitants of the land and from what I hear, many of them were originally from Egypt and Jordan.

I will even concede that some of them are native to the area.
But if we want to go there, in referencing Biblical history, they would be descendants of Canaanites.

But even Canaan was not a self-autonomous, self-ruling area with a distinct identity and culture.
It was made up of multiple tribes with their own cultures and even then did not identify themselves as Canaanites.
Which was a biblical name that historically referenced the area and caught on by the surrounding kingdoms.
And during that time, Canaan was lorded over by the Egyptians whose empire extended to Southern Turkey.

The *right* solution was to create one Israeli state and then integrate the self-identified Palestinians.
But of course, the issue is Islam.
So the next option was a two-state solution in which the Arab nations rejected.

So at this point, I'm like its whatever. :yeshrug:
 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
327,393
Reputation
-34,113
Daps
633,896
Reppin
The Deep State
The facts are the facts.
Israel was ready for a two-state solution.
Arab nations wouldn't entertain it and declared war on Israel.
Israel staved off the Arab nations and came out of the war with more land.

But beside all that, the British mandate gave Israel ownership of the land. That's fact.
Of which the British received from the Ottoman empire who previously controlled the region. Which is also fact.

The idea of a self-autonomous, self-ruling Palestine with a distinct identity and culture did not exist.
So-called Palestinians were just inhabitants of the land and from what I hear, many of them were originally from Egypt and Jordan.

I will even concede that some of them are native to the area.
But if we want to go there, in referencing Biblical history, they would be descendants of Canaanites.

But even Canaan was not a self-autonomous, self-ruling area with a distinct identity and culture.
It was made up of multiple tribes with their own cultures and even then did not identify themselves as Canaanites.
Which was a biblical name that historically referenced the area and caught on by the surrounding kingdoms.
And during that time, Canaan was lorded over by the Egyptians whose empire extended to Southern Turkey.

The *right* solution was to create one Israeli state and then integrate the self-identified Palestinians.
But of course, the issue is Islam.
So the next option was a two-state solution in which the Arab nations rejected.

So at this point, I'm like its whatever. :yeshrug:
:wow:


 

voiture

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
3,909
Reputation
198
Daps
15,877

I agree with Bill Maher 100%.
The peace/land deal is never going to get as good for the Palestinians as it was in years past. Imagine how strong their bargaining position would be today if they had taken the deal in 1947....the Arabs went to war and lost. Israel will never give back land gained through war...those who disagree are free to start another war.
I'm getting close believing these people don't want peace. They have fumbled the bag way too many times on the negotiation table.
'Yesterday's price is not today's price'...
 

FAH1223

Go Wizards, Go Terps, Go Packers!
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
77,200
Reputation
9,360
Daps
231,307
Reppin
WASHINGTON, DC
The facts are the facts.
Israel was ready for a two-state solution.
Arab nations wouldn't entertain it and declared war on Israel.
Israel staved off the Arab nations and came out of the war with more land.

But beside all that, the British mandate gave Israel ownership of the land. That's fact.
Of which the British received from the Ottoman empire who previously controlled the region. Which is also fact.

The idea of a self-autonomous, self-ruling Palestine with a distinct identity and culture did not exist.
So-called Palestinians were just inhabitants of the land and from what I hear, many of them were originally from Egypt and Jordan.

I will even concede that some of them are native to the area.
But if we want to go there, in referencing Biblical history, they would be descendants of Canaanites.

But even Canaan was not a self-autonomous, self-ruling area with a distinct identity and culture.
It was made up of multiple tribes with their own cultures and even then did not identify themselves as Canaanites.
Which was a biblical name that historically referenced the area and caught on by the surrounding kingdoms.
And during that time, Canaan was lorded over by the Egyptians whose empire extended to Southern Turkey.

The *right* solution was to create one Israeli state and then integrate the self-identified Palestinians.
But of course, the issue is Islam.
So the next option was a two-state solution in which the Arab nations rejected.

So at this point, I'm like its whatever. :yeshrug:

:mjlol: this analysis has no mention of what happened in the British Mandate, no mention of the Israeli sabotaging of Oslo, a military occupation of 56 years, a system of apartheid being implemented.

The lazy “oh Islam” is so ignorant. :mjlol:
 

Pressure

#PanthersPosse
Supporter
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
47,349
Reputation
7,226
Daps
150,482
Reppin
CookoutGang
:mjlol: this analysis has no mention of what happened in the British Mandate, no mention of the Israeli sabotaging of Oslo, a military occupation of 56 years, a system of apartheid being implemented.

The lazy “oh Islam” is so ignorant. :mjlol:
To be fair, that’s not the point of contention is it? Isn’t it merely that it was never a self ruling Palestinian state for nearly 500 years prior to Israel?


:gucci:
 

Ethnic Vagina Finder

The Great Paper Chaser
Bushed
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
55,564
Reputation
3,055
Daps
157,121
Reppin
North Jersey but I miss Cali :sadcam:
I agree with Bill Maher 100%.
The peace/land deal is never going to get as good for the Palestinians as it was in years past. Imagine how strong their bargaining position would be today if they had taken the deal in 1947....the Arabs went to war and lost. Israel will never give back land gained through war...those who disagree are free to start another war.
I'm getting close believing these people don't want peace. They have fumbled the bag way too many times on the negotiation table.
'Yesterday's price is not today's price'...

SO you're listening to bill maher now :mjpls:

He knows about has much as you do. The Palestinians didn't go to war with anyone. They got kicked out.

The created of Israel never intended to be 2 states. Zionist Nazi ass cac always intended there to be Israel an nothing else. All of that other bullshyt with the maps was a bullshyt ploy. Every tactic Israel has done for the past 5 decades has been to prevent a 2 state solution.

Even if Hamas agreed to it, Israel would've found a way to sabotage it. Israel is full of liars. They've been caught lying multiple times in the past month. Enough with this bullshyt charade. This is a delayed ethnic cleansing that's been going on for 70 years.
 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
327,393
Reputation
-34,113
Daps
633,896
Reppin
The Deep State
:mjlol: this analysis has no mention of what happened in the British Mandate, no mention of the Israeli sabotaging of Oslo, a military occupation of 56 years, a system of apartheid being implemented.

The lazy “oh Islam” is so ignorant. :mjlol:
shut the fukk up you islamist bootlicker

The Arab world tried this shyt and they lost

Keep up
 
Top