Basically yeahHIP HOP
Listen, fellas....if people want to debate for the sake of debating that's one thing.
Because of where hip hop originated, there's only one logical conclusion that can be reached about it's origin. I would challenge anybody to disagree. Let's examine NYC area from 1920 to roughly 1970
Great Migration of Blacks to the North really began a bit after WW1 started...in mid 19teens
Immigration Act of 1924 closed the lid on non Western European immigration into the country.
The Black and Brown people who were exceptions were Puerto Ricans, who are citizens of US, and people from English speaking Caribbean, who were still British subjects (and qualified for immigration as their countries were part of the UK)
From the early 1920s on, you had AAs from all over the South continuously moving to NYC and bringing their music, church traditions, styles of dance. You had Cariibean people from English speaking islands doing the same. Puerto Ricans, with a strong African cultural presence in their culture, did the same thing. ThEse three groups blended cultures with the AAs whose families were already in NY before any of them came up here. All four groups, living in NYC around each other for 4-5 decades....with influences from other regional AA cultures , mainsteam AA music, and general American pop culture.
Here is an important distinction. America became powerful and culturally inlfuential across the world at that time. Hollywood films played across the world, and American music was played all over the planet....jazz,blues, rock roll,soul,etc. These American music genres were played in the Caribbean and Puerto Rico and had influence on the music that aleady existed there.
I think NYC was one of the only parts of the country where you could say that the reverse was happening. That AAs were regularly being exposed to and being inlfuenced by Caribbean and Puerto Rican music
I believe that this is why the hip hop culture emerged where it did.....not in the Caribbean, not in P.R.., not in the American South, not in another Northern urban area....but in New York City. A perfect storm. It's a stew, the base of the stew is AA, the stove where it's cooked is in America, the ingredients include northern AA , southern AA, Caribbean and Puerto Rican elements.
PERIOD.
And all of those cultures produced the rappers, graffiti artists, dancers and DJs that we all love ... if you look at their roots ....