African History =/= Black History

iFightSeagullsForBread

The Working Class Hero
Joined
Nov 30, 2014
Messages
8,511
Reputation
-880
Daps
27,266
Reppin
Somewhere in Chicago
Technically he has a point, because look at the Samoans while obviously of African lineage, they don't identify with it not only because of colonization, but primarily because of how far removed they are from said heritage.
 

Barnett114

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
26,855
Reputation
17,506
Daps
189,038
Reppin
Chicago
Technically he has a point, because look at the Samoans while obviously of African lineage, they don't identify with it not only because of colonization, but primarily because of how far removed they are from said heritage.

Samoans aren't African in DNA though, they only share the phenotypes.

I mean they got to Samoa 3500 years ago. Long before colonization.
 

OfTheCross

Veteran
Bushed
Joined
Mar 17, 2013
Messages
43,350
Reputation
4,874
Daps
98,671
Reppin
Keeping my overhead low, and my understand high
Maybe I just don't see race the way you do...

I noticed that someone made a delineation between race and ethnicity here in the Americas... That's something I'd like to clear up..

When I'm speaking of Black History in the Americas I am talking about our ethnic history.. Which is what we connect to.

So, to my point, Black ppl in the Americas start their history where their ethnic history begins...be it Haiti, DR, Cuba, or Jamaica.

Why are you guys pretending, or surprised that a Black person in this hemisphere has no historical ties to Africa other than the fact that all black ppl came from Africa?

That African history, although is part of us all, has no true meaning to us.

I never hear anyone say "I'm not Jamaican, I'm African." Or "I'm not Haitian, I'm African"...

For Blacks in the Americas we are people of the Americas culturally. That's our history.
 

↓R↑LYB

I trained Sheng Long and Shonuff
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
44,204
Reputation
13,769
Daps
171,175
Reppin
Pawgistan
Maybe I just don't see race the way you do...

I noticed that someone made a delineation between race and ethnicity here in the Americas... That's something I'd like to clear up..

When I'm speaking of Black History in the Americas I am talking about our ethnic history.. Which is what we connect to.

So, to my point, Black ppl in the Americas start their history where their ethnic history begins...be it Haiti, DR, Cuba, or Jamaica.

Why are you guys pretending, or surprised that a Black person in this hemisphere has no historical ties to Africa other than the fact that all black ppl came from Africa?

That African history, although is part of us all, has no true meaning to us.

I never hear anyone say "I'm not Jamaican, I'm African." Or "I'm not Haitian, I'm African"...

For Blacks in the Americas we are people of the Americas culturally. That's our history.

Are you Dominican by any chance :patrice:
 

Birnin Zana

Honorary Wakandan
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
6,106
Reputation
1,570
Daps
22,955
Reppin
Wakanda
I'm not only talking about Americans. I'm talking about all Blacks in the Americas. We all got here the same way...but our history starts with our arrival here.

No it does not, that's the point.

Black people in the Americas are the only group of people who ended up in the new world by force, not willingly. It's not as if they choice to leave their ancestral home behind, like whites have. And black peoples culture was forcibly erased, unlike others. Hence they had to recreate an identity by scratch.

Your ancestors had a language, culture, and were part of a nation of peoples. There's more to them than being sent to the new world as slaves.
 

Blackking

Banned
Supporter
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
21,566
Reputation
2,486
Daps
26,223
Also brother Malcolm disagrees with you......but according to some Bro Malcolm wasn't a #RealBlack anyway
malcolmmjpls-png.3184


http://www.blackpast.org/1964-malcolm-x-s-speech-founding-rally-organization-afro-american-unity
:stopitslime:nikka

Malcolm was a c00n off the strength of him being Muslim according to the coli.

:camby:Nobody trying to hear about that diet negro
 

filial_piety

Banned
Joined
Jun 21, 2012
Messages
11,107
Reputation
-2,760
Daps
27,468
Reppin
I95S
I'm not only talking about Americans. I'm talking about all Blacks in the Americas. We all got here the same way...but our history starts with our arrival here.
I agree. With AA's it does start here and unfortunately it's with an immoral past.
 

Poitier

My Words Law
Supporter
Joined
Jul 30, 2013
Messages
69,411
Reputation
15,449
Daps
246,375
Your ancestors had a language, culture, and were part of a nation of peoples. There's more to them than being sent to the new world as slaves.

Who said AA culture is just slavery? Are you claiming AAs are not "part of a nation of peoples" with a culture?

In 2015, AA culture is more salient than African culture.
 

OfTheCross

Veteran
Bushed
Joined
Mar 17, 2013
Messages
43,350
Reputation
4,874
Daps
98,671
Reppin
Keeping my overhead low, and my understand high
No it does not, that's the point.

Black people in the Americas are the only group of people who ended up in the new world by force, not willingly. It's not as if they choice to leave their ancestral home behind, like whites have. And black peoples culture was forcibly erased, unlike others. Hence they had to recreate an identity by scratch.

Your ancestors had a language, culture, and were part of a nation of peoples. There's more to them than being sent to the new world as slaves.

Understood. But none if that is our culture now.

You know who relates more to that? The Africans that are actually over there. They still have that language and culture and nation.

We have our own languages, cultures and nations here now.

So our race may be the same, but we're not the same ppl and don't have the same history.[/QUOTE]
 
Top