Aaron Rodgers Is Already The GOAT. There Are No Arguments To Be Made Against It.

[Bboystyle]

Sorry breh but this is very emotional outburst by you.

And what you said is not quite true. It's not simply rings. It's 1)longevity and 2)playoff performances against comparable qbs

Simply put, nfl players are measured by performance, not individual talent. When player a and player b are comparable but player b has 4 more rings, player b career performance is simply better in the grand scheme of things.

Now I'm one of the biggest "defense wins games" advocates you'll see out there. No qb wins games by themselves. However if we're talking about the greatest qb of all time he has to have good playoffs. Very good playoffs performances. This is what Marino stans don't understand. It's not that Marino doesn't have rings.... it's that in the biggest game of his life he shat the bed. Yes the defenses are great in the offs. But once again we are talking about GOAT qb not just hall of fame top 5 qb

Now this applies less to arod but it applies nonetheless. Another sb trip and 3 or so years playing at a high level will cement him as top 3 . he needs more playoff beasting to surpass Joe and Tom.

And - I'm sure you know this - I'm a Cal fan who has always been a fan of Arod and he's easily been the best qb in the game for years now.

Rodgers does have good playoffs, thats what u guys are missing. his 101 rating is third all time highest and highest for current players. A QB can be masterful in the playoffs but the team could still lose. Hell look at Rodgers first playoff game. he threw for 4 TD's and over 400 yards. Now normally that would be good enough to win them the game but guess what? his defense allowed over 45+ points so they loss. Yet Rodgers is hold accountable when talking rings and playoff wins?

 

[dh86]

They keep using the argument after his super bowl winning season

2010 is five years ago.

 

[yseJ]

Rodgers does have good playoffs, thats what u guys are missing. his 101 rating is third all time highest and highest for current players. A QB can be masterful in the playoffs but the team could still lose. Hell look at Rodgers first playoff game. he threw for 4 TD's and over 400 yards. Now normally that would be good enough to win them the game but guess what? his defense allowed over 45+ points so they loss. Yet Rodgers is hold accountable when talking rings and playoff wins?

I never said he doesn't own good playoffs stats. He needs more in a bigger sample size. And as long as he's comparable to Brady and Montana, the rings will be in conversation. It's how shyt goes. Arod is on pace to surpass those guys tho to the point they aren't comparable. When that happens I can say he's the goat qb.

 

[mastermind]

furthermore, fukk this argument that Rodgers had to sit three years behind Farve, at least Rodgers was a starter in college, Brady was seventh string at Michigan, having to split time with Drew Henson his last two years in Ann Arbor. Rodgers was a first round pick, 20th I believe, Brady was 196th. Brady started his professional career as the fourth string quarterback, behind starter Drew Bledsoe and backups John Friesz and Michael Bishop; by season's end, he was number two on the depth chart behind Bledsoe.
-Wikipedia

No one is arguing that his numbers would be better had he played those three years.

The argument is that her per game numbers blows everyone out the fukking water.

People are deliberately being obtuse about this. I am a Brady stan. 13 years and counting and fukked with him at Michigan. He not better than Rodgers. Rodgers is basically every QB we have talked about rolled into one. He got the mental game of Peyton. He got the Marino quick release. Sonny Jurgenson's gunslinger mentality. Staubach's scrambling ability. Favre's arm strength. Aikman's accuracy. Steve Young's decision making. Brady/Montana coolness.

He the perfect QB and people don't want to accept that he is taking the piss out of this position.

 

[DrexlersFade]

2010 is five years ago.

So what you have stafford on your avi Peyton ain't won in 9 and Tom went 10 until last year Duncan went 7 years Kobe went 7 years what's your point?

Plus once again you have Stafford in your AVi stay outta Rodgers disscussions we don't need that shyt wearing off.

Would you give your right arm for Rodgers

 

[Ian1362]

Aaron Rodgers is 6-5 in the playoffs and is 2-4 with 2 home losses since 2010. If he's the greatest, he gotta own that just like Peyton owns 11-13. The greats don't need caveats

Rodgers has had his defense give up 51, 37, and 45 points in playoff games. In his entire career Tom Brady has only had his defense give up 30 points or more in a playoff game three times (vs Ravens last year, 2009 debacle to Ravens, 2006 Conf Champ) and lost two of the three. Joe Montana 0-2 in same circumstances.


Also, thru 3 games, Rodgers is off the second best start in NFL history behind Tom Brady's 16-0 season:

Player Game Finder Query Results | Pro-Football-Reference.com\

Meanwhile, the Lions are yet again terrible

 

[thelonious21]

He's my QB on both my FF Teams

 

[DrexlersFade]

No one is arguing that his numbers would be better had he played those three years.

The argument is that her per game numbers blows everyone out the fukking water.

People are deliberately being obtuse about this. I am a Brady stan. 13 years and counting and fukked with him at Michigan. He not better than Rodgers. Rodgers is basically every QB we have talked about rolled into one. He got the mental game of Peyton. He got the Marino quick release. Sonny Jurgenson's gunslinger mentality. Staubach's scrambling ability. Favre's arm strength. Aikman's accuracy. Steve Young's decision making. Brady/Montana coolness.

He the perfect QB and people don't want to accept that he is taking the piss out of this position.

WTF is dudes in here talking about you read the thread title...Plus he only getting better

 

[Ian1362]

Pats win the SB this year and next

Last year Rodgers threw all over the Patriots with Revis and Browner.

EDIT: Packers in general whoop on the Patriots

Outplayed them last year, outphysicaled them in the preseason this year, 2010 McCarthy "we're nobodies underdogs, dominant Patriots team that was winning every game 40-7 needed a miracle Dan Connoly kick return to beat Matt Flynn, Packers traded down with Patriots, take Greg Jennings while Patriots take Chad Jackson, 2009 trade up and rip off Patriots to draft Clay Matthews, Patriots get Darius Butler and Brandon Tate, etc

 

[dh86]

So what you have stafford on your avi Peyton ain't won in 9 and Tom went 10 until last year Duncan went 7 years Kobe went 7 years what's your point?

Plus once again you have Stafford in your AVi stay outta Rodgers disscussions we don't need that shyt of wearing off.

Would you give your right arm for Rodgers

Emotional aren't ya

 

[Basaglia]

No one is arguing that his numbers would be better had he played those three years.

The argument is that her per game numbers blows everyone out the fukking water.

People are deliberately being obtuse about this. I am a Brady stan. 13 years and counting and fukked with him at Michigan. He not better than Rodgers. Rodgers is basically every QB we have talked about rolled into one. He got the mental game of Peyton. He got the Marino quick release. Sonny Jurgenson's gunslinger mentality. Staubach's scrambling ability. Favre's arm strength. Aikman's accuracy. Steve Young's decision making. Brady/Montana coolness.

He the perfect QB and people don't want to accept that he is taking the piss out of this position.

COOL! he should win the most rings in history. AND he should maintain his per game averages for the next 7-10 years.

And Steve Young made some of the WORST decisions at the WORST moments of any elite QB.

 

[DrexlersFade]

Emotional aren't ya

Not at all season going great for me I'm a good space how about ya self

Keep that filthy AVI from around Rodgers threads

This thread has been baptised everything Stafford and The Lions

 

[SubZeroDegrees]

I thought it was common knowledge Arod is the QB in the league and soon to be GOAT QB.

 

[joe cool]

He wanted to be a niner. We wanted alex smith

 

[JarrodG]

People proping Rodgers as the GOAT probably the same people who thinks Luck is better than KillaCam