Aaron Rodgers Is Already The GOAT. There Are No Arguments To Be Made Against It.
- Thread starter Monster
- Start date
Bboystyle
Bang Bang Packers gang!
still no legitimate reason behind your logic. Nice try though
and Steve Young with dementia holds more value in his opinion in football then some random alias on the coli
Is Joe Montana still alive?
SymbolicOne09
All Star
He's gotta win more rings. But there is no more complete qb then him
protestor
Man of the year
Goat QB's
Montana
Manning
Marino.
Rodgers is not on that level yet.
Montana
Manning
Marino.
Rodgers is not on that level yet.
Amare's Right Hook
Southeast World Champion
Brady phags blown the phuck out.
OneManGang
Veteran
Sitting 3 years and injuries will keep A-Rod from being up in the record books with these guys but saying he isn't on Manning's level especially is ridiculous. Manning was never this good. And that's taking nothing away from a Hall of Famer.
daemonova
hit it, & I didn't go Erykah Badu crazy, #yallmad
now we playing the what if game
Sitting 3 years and injuries will keep A-Rod from being up in the record books with these guys but saying he isn't on Manning's level especially is ridiculous. Manning was never this good. And that's taking nothing away from a Hall of Famer.
duckbutta
eienaar van mans
Just because he's a beast doesn't mean that the rest of his team is.
The rest of his team doesn't have to be if he is "the greatest of all time"
Like...does he need to be the greatest QB ever AND have the greatest supporting cast ever...
Cause if he does then he can't be the greatest of all time...
Cause if he was the greatest of all time he wouldn't need a great supporting cast...
Yall moving the goalposts, Super Joe is the GOAT QB
But SKILL wise, AGawd is that dude.
duckbutta
eienaar van mans
OP needs to change this to the Aaron Rodgers excuses thread...
Thread: He is the greatest ever
Duckbutta: Why is only got one ring though...I mean if he is the best ever of all time surely he should have more than one championship...because in ever other sport the person considered the best ever has more than 1 title...
Thread : B-b-but the defense...but but but the GM...but but but the ground game...but but but it's a team sport...but but but it's not all on him...
So Rodgers is the best ever...but he only got 1 ring...but it's a team sport...but the GM has not drafted blah blah blah...but the defense is not blah blah blah...but he take all these receivers you never heard of and makes them stars...but Dan Marino doesn't have any rings...but Dez didn't catch the ball....but the nfc east is weak :yeah ok:
The greatest QB of all time hasn't won the number of championships Eli Manning lucked into huh:yeah ok:
But somehow the QB's who won twice as many superbowls as Eli lucked into are NOT the guys who are in consideration for the GOAT QB:yeah ok:
Coli logic:yeah ok:
Thread: He is the greatest ever
Duckbutta: Why is only got one ring though...I mean if he is the best ever of all time surely he should have more than one championship...because in ever other sport the person considered the best ever has more than 1 title...
Thread : B-b-but the defense...but but but the GM...but but but the ground game...but but but it's a team sport...but but but it's not all on him...
So Rodgers is the best ever...but he only got 1 ring...but it's a team sport...but the GM has not drafted blah blah blah...but the defense is not blah blah blah...but he take all these receivers you never heard of and makes them stars...but Dan Marino doesn't have any rings...but Dez didn't catch the ball....but the nfc east is weak :yeah ok:
The greatest QB of all time hasn't won the number of championships Eli Manning lucked into huh:yeah ok:
But somehow the QB's who won twice as many superbowls as Eli lucked into are NOT the guys who are in consideration for the GOAT QB:yeah ok:
Coli logic:yeah ok:
OneManGang
Veteran
That's not what if at all. Rodgers per game stats are all better. He just won't play as long as those guys to get those all time numbers.
Why y'all be acting like Jennings, Jordy, Adams, Cobb was some diamonds in the rough that no one scouted? Like they NEEDED A-Rod to not be sorry? They were all projected first or second round. MUST WE CYSE SHYT TO DEATH TO PROP UP RODGERS?
Now, Deion Branch, Troy Brown and David Givens, who started in the 2005 SB (yanno, Tom's THIRD)...THEM NYGGAS WERE ACTUALLY SORRY!
so, stop with all this, man.
nobody saying rodgers ain't a beast. but he aint the best ever. shyt, if you like the way he throw the ball. GREAT. Warren Moon threw the best ball I've ever seen...loves watching him throw. But, I ain't calling GOAT off a bamma giving me chills when he makes a nice throw. Y'all breaking all kinda fans traditions tryna promote a 1-ring QB to GOAT.
Now, Deion Branch, Troy Brown and David Givens, who started in the 2005 SB (yanno, Tom's THIRD)...THEM NYGGAS WERE ACTUALLY SORRY!
so, stop with all this, man.
nobody saying rodgers ain't a beast. but he aint the best ever. shyt, if you like the way he throw the ball. GREAT. Warren Moon threw the best ball I've ever seen...loves watching him throw. But, I ain't calling GOAT off a bamma giving me chills when he makes a nice throw. Y'all breaking all kinda fans traditions tryna promote a 1-ring QB to GOAT.