madeyoulook
Pro
So I got around to playing Alan Wake...
It just felt too easy, as you said.
Everybody who suggested it summed up exactly what I asked for in suggesting Alan Wake, so, no knock to you all and thanks again.
But I just was not feeling that joint, man
I couldn't get into the whole light vs dark undertone and killing enemies with a flashlight.
The storyline was
I just couldn't get into it. Played it for like 20 mins, kicked a bunch of ass, and it all just left a lot to be desired, in my opinion.
But again, everyone has exactly the right idea with that type of suggestion of a game(Alan Wake).
I just couldn't get into that one.. that slow movement..the way the game is dark the majority of the time.. and it was a little too simple to dominate.
Skyrim or Assassin's Creed 3 will be my next conquest.. with Bioshock series, and Metal Gear series as backups if there's no availability for AC3 or Skyrim
Anymore suggestions still welcome!
Alan Wake is a boring game. Same with Last of Us or Uncharted. They try hard with the stories and ignore the combat.
Skyrim's combat is kinda
but that is only if you go purely as a melee character. The exploration and some of the quests make up for it though 
Skyrim should be your next buy if you don't want disappointment.