9/30/2023: SHO PPV - Canelo vs Charlo (Undisputed Super Middleweight Championship)

Who Wins?


  • Total voters
    155
  • Poll closed .

reservoirdogs

Superstar
Joined
Jun 1, 2016
Messages
12,707
Reputation
1,030
Daps
25,527
Mel has a good chin, and Canelo isn't a destructive puncher, and he himself started at 154.

I imagine Mel manages to see a decision. I wonder how he'll adjust to fighting with the extra 11+ pounds.

It's a fun matchup though. With Canelo beginning to show signs of slippage, and Mel enjoying his success at 154, there's just enough plausibility to think that Mel has a shot of upsetting Nelo. At least moreso than his brother, who was out for too long.
Castano had him hurt, idk man…
I’m not giving a solid chance to Jermell and it’s farcial that Canelo drags someone up 2 divisions.
Jermell is a good fighter obviously but not good enough of a boxer to neutralize Canelo and no good enough of a puncher to take him out, esp with the difference in weight classes.
He struggled with Harrison and Castano and tbf he closed both of those rivalries convincingly but how am I gonna believe you give 168lbs Canelo serious issues after that.
 

Dallas' 4 Eva

Superstar
Joined
Jun 29, 2018
Messages
12,144
Reputation
2,596
Daps
42,277
You're comparing Brian Castano to Canelos Alvarez. Come on man, be real. This is a farce ass fight. The only way Jermell isn't brutally stopped is if Canelo has lost a step significant enough to even the playing field. Other than that Charlo is getting his ass WHOOPED. To me this is career suicide. This is not a diss to Jermell, who is a very good fighter. But he's jumping up in weight to fight an all time great who still has some juice left. He will get hurt badly if Canelo is even 75 % of himself. But hey, this is boxing. Anything can happen.
DAMN ALL THAT BULLshyt YOU TALKING BRUH, I GOT MELL BY KO!!! :demonic::hhh:

With all due respect of course. :whoa:
 

((ReFleXioN)) EteRNaL

RIP MR. SMOKE
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
19,590
Reputation
7,264
Daps
93,681
This is basically a super middle version of Shane Mosley vs Delahoya. Everybody expected Oscar would be too big and strong. Which is why he was a 2 to 1 favorite. But it was Mosley's athleticism and quickness that came out on top. And surprisingly he also looked like the stronger guy. Oscar just couldn't keep up. This could very well go the same way. Especially since canelo's defense and speed has slipped over the past couple years. Jermell has the fresher legs and better stamina.

Derrick James wouldn't have taken this fight if he didn't believed jermell could win. This is gonna be a very high level chess match. Won't be a walk in the park for canelo in the slightest. I favor canelo 60-40 but he's gonna have some problems with Jermell's athleticism and skill. These are the types of fights boxing needs. That arena is going to be fukkin madness on fight night. In the meantime David's fat ass can take on Morell, jermall, or Andrade. That fights not going anywhere. If he can't make it past them then he was never built for canelo anyway.
 

JealousOnesEn_V

HTX Certified
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
2,553
Reputation
401
Daps
8,061
I don’t think you really understand weight differences in boxing. And that’s okay, not everyone understands the nuances of sports.

I don’t think you really understand that you should be receiving an SSI check every month for your intellectual and developmental disabilities…
 

krackdagawd

Inspire.
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
45,733
Reputation
8,246
Daps
139,899
Reppin
Another Gold Medal
But please tell us how this is a difficult fight for Alvarez?

He's fighting someone two/three weight classes below him!

How is this even allowed to be signed off by the Nevada Athletics Commission?

I rock with him. But I'm not going to fan boy cheerlead him or Charlo in this thread like others blindly are.

Canelo did the same exact thing Charlo doing. If Charlo wins that he should get the same props Canelo got for kkkov.

I know being the biggest draw makes the whole boxing world nitpick at every single thing you do but it’s getting wild af w Canelo.
 

CBalla

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
4,919
Reputation
342
Daps
15,039
mell taller with a longer reach than nelo, and bigger too, no excuses, doubt he wins but i hope he does
 

JP_614

Superstar
Joined
May 31, 2012
Messages
16,379
Reputation
3,231
Daps
32,954
Reppin
Aloha State
This may be career suicide for jermell charlo. yeah, I'm sorry, but this is shameful for Canelo and PBC. It should have been Benavidez.
To be honest save that fight for cinco de mayo weekend next year. May be next year still a huge fight but if Canelo fights 2 times a year it’s usually cinco de Mayo and in September. So he’s on course. We just gotta hope they both get through their oppositions.
 

Thatrogueassdiaz

We're on the blood path now
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
28,701
Reputation
4,308
Daps
50,931
Reppin
Center self, inner self
Nah actually it does make sense to let it marinate. Right now an excuse is lined up. Benavidez only has one notable win, and not much big fight experience. This will be used to discredit Canelo's win. Canelo about knock off both the Charlo twins. In this time frame, Benavidez has the opportunity update his resume, wit 1 or 2 more credible wins. It should go this way, bc haters quick to trying discredit, and water down all the work Canelo put in
No, it doesn't. The hype for the fight is here now. You marinate a fight to increase the demand. Benavidez just beat one of his main rivals at 168. He's the interim champion. Everyone wants to see it. Let's say the fight does better on Cinco De Mayo, than it does Mexican independence day (which may be the reasoning), then why have this farce of a fight now?
Like Canelo just whooped and brutally stopped John Ryder right? :deadrose:
Who is a rugged 168lb, not a guy who has never fought at 160/168 and is jumping up to face the best fighter in his division. This is like Adames or Lara at 160, jumping up to fight Beterbiev at 175. Does that even make sense?
Canelo started at WELTERWEIGHT, he isn’t a natural light heavyweight what are you talking about??
I hope you're not suggesting that someone's natural weight class is the weight class they start at?
 
Top