XXL & 5Mics Rating

Artfull Dodger

All Star
Joined
Jul 20, 2012
Messages
2,120
Reputation
1,367
Daps
7,126
THE SOURCE MAG
Albums that originally received five mics:
 People's Instinctive Travels and the Paths of Rhythm -- A Tribe Called Quest
 Let the Rhythm Hit 'Em -- Eric B. & Rakim
 AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted -- Ice Cube
 One for All -- Brand Nubian
 De La Soul Is Dead -- De La Soul
 The Low End Theory -- A Tribe Called Quest
 Illmatic -- Nas
 Life After Death -- The Notorious B.I.G.
 Aquemini -- Outkast
 The Blueprint -- Jay-Z
 Stillmatic -- Nas
 The Fix -- Scarface
 The Naked Truth -- Lil' Kim
 Trill OG -- Bun B
 My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy -- Kanye West

Albums that were not rated upon their releases, but were later rated five mics in 2002:
 Run-D.M.C. -- Run-D.M.C.
 Radio -- LL Cool J
 Licensed to Ill -- Beastie Boys
 Raising Hell -- Run-D.M.C.
 Criminal Minded -- Boogie Down Productions
 Paid in Full -- Eric B. & Rakim
 By All Means Necessary -- Boogie Down Productions
 It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back -- Public Enemy
 Long Live the Kane -- Big Daddy Kane
 Critical Beatdown -- Ultramagnetic MCs
 Straight Out the Jungle -- Jungle Brothers
 Strictly Business -- EPMD
 The Great Adventures of Slick Rick -- Slick Rick
 Straight Outta Compton -- N.W.A.
 No One Can Do It Better -- The D.O.C.
 All Eyez on Me -- 2Pac
Albums that originally received 4.5 Mics, and were later re-rated to five:
 Breaking Atoms -- Main Source
 Death Certificate -- Ice Cube
 The Chronic -- Dr. Dre
 Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers) -- Wu-Tang Clan
 Ready to Die -- The Notorious B.I.G.
 The Infamous -- Mobb Deep
 Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... -- Raekwon
 2001 -- Dr. Dre
Albums that originally received four mics, and were later re-rated to five:
 Grip It! On That Other Level -- Geto Boys
 Doggystyle -- Snoop Doggy Dogg
 The Diary -- Scarface
 Me Against the World -- 2Pac
 The Score -- The Fugees
 Reasonable Doubt -- Jay-Z

XXL MAG
XXL rates albums from "S" (poor) to "XXL" (classic). Initially, editors awarded XXL status to only eight albums:
 The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill by Lauryn Hill
 The Blueprint by Jay-Z
 Get Rich or Die Tryin' by 50 Cent
 Be by Common
 Late Registration by Kanye West
 Hell Hath No Fury by Clipse
 My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy by Kanye West
 Life Is Good by Nas
A later issue in December 2007 re-rated and retroactively rated some albums and gave XXLs to:[9]
 The Chronic by Dr. Dre *
 Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers) by Wu-Tang Clan *
 Illmatic by Nas *
 The Diary by Scarface *
 The Infamous by Mobb Deep *
 All Eyez on Me by 2Pac *
 Reasonable Doubt by Jay-Z *
 The Don Killuminati: The 7 Day Theory by 2Pac *
 Life After Death by The Notorious B.I.G. *
 2001 by Dr. Dre
 The Marshall Mathers LP by Eminem
 The Lost Tapes by Nas
 The College Dropout by Kanye West
 Asterisk (*) denotes an album that was released before the existence of XXL magazine, meaning this is their original rating, not a re-rate.

Which Albums do yo think deserve to be rated as XXL and 5Mic? And Which Albums do you think are unrecognized Classics that didn’t make these lists??

51994861.png
 

BStapies

All Star
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
3,392
Reputation
-140
Daps
5,041
Reppin
NULL
The graduation is better than MBDTF

How did that get a 5 and TG didnt?
 

H.J.Duck

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
4,907
Reputation
880
Daps
13,176
The graduation is better than MBDTF

How did that get a 5 and TG didnt?


because despite being the better album Graduation isn't a 5 mic album either. MBDTF is just overrated by 90% of journalists :manny:



the whole "unique" & "original" one new song/week & "cool" artistic long ass movie/music video and weird shyt Kanye did meant more to some of the fans/bloggers/journalists so it made the album seem more monumental it actually was :ehh:
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
1,360
Reputation
0
Daps
1,381
Reppin
http://youtu.be/pXzHOOuCYZc
because despite being the better album Graduation isn't a 5 mic album either. MBDTF is just overrated by 90% of journalists :manny:



the whole "unique" & "original" one new song/week & "cool" artistic long ass movie/music video and weird shyt Kanye did meant more to some of the fans/bloggers/journalists so it made the album seem more monumental it actually was :ehh:
It was the exact opposite for me. All the GOOD Fridays were dope. So I was thinking damn if these are throw away tracks whats gonna be on this album :ohhh:

Then the track list came out and I had heard half the damn album already :beli: I appreciate the freebies but it def killed the initial listening experience.
 

Harry B

Superstar
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
30,796
Reputation
-1,306
Daps
61,913
Lol @ MBDTF not being a 5 mic album.
Dudes ears for music is at an all-time low, typical the coli/the spot shyt.
Dudes can't even understand a song like All of the lights and they say he's trying to hard.
Dudes can't see how every instrument plays a role in the building of the beat and they say it's overproduced.
He tries fresh and original shyt, cats say that he's pseudo artistic.



As far as this thread, I still don't know how they couldn't upgrade ATLiens to a 5 mic album.
 

Black Magisterialness

Moderna Boi
Supporter
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
19,433
Reputation
4,055
Daps
46,566
because despite being the better album Graduation isn't a 5 mic album either. MBDTF is just overrated by 90% of journalists :manny:



the whole "unique" & "original" one new song/week & "cool" artistic long ass movie/music video and weird shyt Kanye did meant more to some of the fans/bloggers/journalists so it made the album seem more monumental it actually was :ehh:

i feel what you saying be hey it worked :pachaha:

MBDTF is one of the few albums that still gets regular rotation from me despite its age and as far as straight rap went there weren't really any albums on that level.

Late Registration is still by far his best imo
 
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
65,556
Reputation
28,507
Daps
390,834
Reppin
Ft. Stewart, Ga
Lol @ MBDTF not being a 5 mic album.
Dudes ears for music is at an all-time low, typical the coli/the spot shyt.
Dudes can't even understand a song like All of the lights and they say he's trying to hard.
Dudes can't see how every instrument plays a role in the building of the beat and they say it's overproduced.


As far as this thread, I still don't know how they couldn't upgrade ATLiens to a 5 mic album.

I remember reading somewhere that Benzino HATED Outkast for some reason and didn't want ever wanna give them props....
 

Harry B

Superstar
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
30,796
Reputation
-1,306
Daps
61,913
I remember reading somewhere that Benzino HATED Outkast for some reason and didn't want ever wanna give them props....
But they gave Aquemini 5 mics though?
I mean 4 mics in 96 wasn't exactly bad, they basically got the same rating as RD, Ironman and IWW. I don't know, I just felt like it was the first southern album that was getting that 5 mic love up north from everyone but the source (I'm not old enough to remember how it was when geto boys first came through with their classics). Scarface didn't get that love either but was later given his right props for The Diary.
 
Top