It did not give me the immediate and permanently sustaining satisfaction of XBC1, but that is arguably my favorite game ever, so there's no shame here.
The sidequests are overly bloated, the map system is tedious at times and the system can be deep to a fault, but I promise you brehs who haven't played it yet, if you pace yourself, really dig into it, and maybe don't bother with side quests that annoy you too much, you will be rewarded with a fantastic party of characters, a story that is very well written, one of the best world's in gaming, and a top tier battle system.
I give it a 8.5 and I pre ordered the prequel
Zeke is the GOAT lol. I will revisit this game again some day off the strength of me hearing you can actually use the Eye of Shining justice the second go round
PS: The way it ties to the first game was so beautifully done. It's one of those things only people who beat the first game will get, and even though it isn't necessary to understand for people who haven't played the first, I was smiling hard AF when I pieced it together.