Drip Bayless
Superstar
I do agree we can not and should not absolve people of the responsibility of their choices, my point was that to boil the discussion down to "They're stupid and racist. End of story." is both lazy and politically useless. If the goal is to actually change things, then just blaming voters for being dumb and racist ignores the larger forces at play that shape their decisions. People have agency, but agency isn’t exercised in a vacuum. Utah’s union workers, for example, aren’t just making individual choices independent of their environment, they are living in a deeply entrenched conservative political and media ecosystem that has spent decades conditioning them to vote against their own material interests. Simply lecturing or ridiculing them isn’t a political strategy. If people are enabling their own exploitation, the question isn’t just "why are they so stupid?" It’s why does the alt right's message resonate more than the Dem’s, and what can be done to counteract that? You don’t fix a broken political consciousness by scolding people, you fix it by offering an alternative that is stronger and more emotionally compelling than the one they’re currently followingI agree with most of what you're saying. Structural forces *are* real, but people aren't mindless puppets; they still have agency and make choices, even under a rigged system. Writing off voter responsibility ignores the fact that many *do* break through the propaganda, organize, and fight for change. The problem isn't just the system, it's also the refusal to hold voters accountable for enabling it, even when the truth is right in front of them.
Take Utah for example. It is a pretty big union state, but it has a red trifecta government. And now that government is on the verge of killing collective bargaining. These voters aren't ignorant of what's happening, they see the policies, feel the consequences, and still double down on supporting the same politicians stripping away their power. That's not just systemic manipulation; it's voters enabling a system that eats them alive and still asking for more. Structural forces might set the stage, but at some point, voters have to own the role they play in sustaining their own exploitation.