Why does it feel like Jonathan Kuminga is still being slept on?

Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
85,177
Reputation
9,397
Daps
230,277
I get what you’re trying to do with the whole ‘boxscore man’, but it ain’t gonna work scrap. Ain’t nobody lookin at box scores and basing their whole conclusion on that that. Don’t be dense. Also know the game, play the game, probably older than. You can’t tell me shyt about hoops I ain’t learned, experienced, done, and shyt out. With that introduction out the way…if you wanna talk normal be my guest. Or just talk keep taking in circles as if anyone gives a shyt about your personal eye test. I promise I don’t.
Every time I see you up in a thread talking about hoops you're getting carried away, letting box score stats lead you astray, when the game doesn't work like that. That's just what it is. It ain't an attack on your character or anything, just your arguments. Bringing up the point about him shooting above 50% when All-Stars and HOFers haven't is a red herring. It's a pointless thing to bring up when the volume is that low you can't take anything of value away from his percentages.

You're not going to see his game for what it is if you're looking at the box score.
And, no, Kuminga wasn’t top 3, he was #4. Green, Cade, and Mobley were solidified top 3 and they went top 3. So Kuminga as the 4th best HS player ending up going 7 isn’t anything to write home about, it was a slight deviation. Especially since the guys ahead of him were right there as highly ranked
Ranked #3 - https://n.rivals.com/content/prospects/2020/jonathan-kuminga-208382.

I guess the point here is that he was in that discussion, so he could've easily improved his stock if he went to college, which he would've had more opportunity of doing so rather than the route he took. Which if he did raise his stock, he would've been in the #1 conversation - keyword being conversation here.
Lol @ ‘I don’t know what you’re getting at’. Kuminga at 19 is ahead of where Jalen brown was at 20. You go check Jaylen brown rookie tape or pull up some win shares or VORP or whatever it is you do and holla at me in 2 years
Kuminga is ahead of Jaylen at the same stage, but that's got nothing to do with their respective box score stats, which are marginal, at best. Which is why I don't understand bringing him up and those stats in the first place. There's nothing of note in Kuminga's surface stats that is going to reflect what he does on the floor and what his potential is.

Only the tape is going to reveal that, and not some archaic measurements that were only used to give a general outlook of the game at its inception.
 

Braman

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
14,427
Reputation
3,296
Daps
57,992
Every time I see you up in a thread talking about hoops you're getting carried away, letting box score stats lead you astray, when the game doesn't work like that. That's just what it is. It ain't an attack on your character or anything, just your arguments. Bringing up the point about him shooting above 50% when All-Stars and HOFers haven't is a red herring. It's a pointless thing to bring up when the volume is that low you can't take anything of value away from his percentages.

You're not going to see his game for what it is if you're looking at the box score.

Ranked #3 - https://n.rivals.com/content/prospects/2020/jonathan-kuminga-208382.

I guess the point here is that he was in that discussion, so he could've easily improved his stock if he went to college, which he would've had more opportunity of doing so rather than the route he took. Which if he did raise his stock, he would've been in the #1 conversation - keyword being conversation here.

Kuminga is ahead of Jaylen at the same stage, but that's got nothing to do with their respective box score stats, which are marginal, at best. Which is why I don't understand bringing him up and those stats in the first place. There's nothing of note in Kuminga's surface stats that is going to reflect what he does on the floor and what his potential is.

Only the tape is going to reveal that, and not some archaic measurements that were only used to give a general outlook of the game at its inception.
There is nothing the tape shows that the box score won’t validate. If the box actor can’t validate it something is wrong. The exception maybe being James harden foul baiting shenanigans and stat padding

Otherwise, eye test and anecdotes fade: the box score better match up.

Steph is the greatest shooter ever…yep, it checks out

Shaq is the most dominant big man ever. Yep, checks out

Rodman the best rebounder ever. That’s not just from memory my G we have actual facts to back it up. “Box scores”

Ie I don’t need to watch tape to know if a guy is a shooter. Show me his 3pt % that’s literally all I need to know. “box scores”
 

10bandz

RIP to the GOAT
Supporter
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
43,109
Reputation
7,692
Daps
213,937
There is nothing the tape shows that the box score won’t validate. If the box actor can’t validate it something is wrong. The exception maybe being James harden foul baiting shenanigans and stat padding

Otherwise, eye test and anecdotes fade: the box score better match up.

Steph is the greatest shooter ever…yep, it checks out

Shaq is the most dominant big man ever. Yep, checks out

Rodman the best rebounder ever. That’s not just from memory my G we have actual facts to back it up. “Box scores”

Ie I don’t need to watch tape to know if a guy is a shooter. Show me his 3pt % that’s literally all I need to know. “box scores”

stop being lazy and just watch the games bozo
 

Braman

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
14,427
Reputation
3,296
Daps
57,992
stop being lazy and just watch the games bozo
That’s corny fam. Never said I don’t watch the games. But watching games ain’t the end all be all. There’s 30 teams 82 games 12 players. I am humble enough to say I do not have a literal or metaphorical file on every player. No one does—-except literal scouts. If you can’t cop to that you trying too hard.

Not to mention, this is the league. ALL these nggas can bump. It’s the consistency that sets guys apart. And THAT is captured in the mfin box score. statistics. Over 82 games, multiple years, they won’t lie to you. Ie If you ‘just watched’ a Nick young or a Lance Stephenson at the right time of the year you’d think they were all-nba players. Checking the stats however shows they ain’t consistent.

I don’t trust anybody on some ‘watch the games’ bc a) I know you can’t watch all of em so I already know you doin too much, and b) everybody’s eye ain’t the same. You can watch a million games and not understand what the next person gets in one watch. ‘Watch the game’ like you Pete Carril out here stop it
 
Last edited:
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
85,177
Reputation
9,397
Daps
230,277
There is nothing the tape shows that the box score won’t validate. If the box actor can’t validate it something is wrong. The exception maybe being James harden foul baiting shenanigans and stat padding

Otherwise, eye test and anecdotes fade: the box score better match up.

Steph is the greatest shooter ever…yep, it checks out

Shaq is the most dominant big man ever. Yep, checks out

Rodman the best rebounder ever. That’s not just from memory my G we have actual facts to back it up. “Box scores”

Ie I don’t need to watch tape to know if a guy is a shooter. Show me his 3pt % that’s literally all I need to know. “box scores”
If you believe this, well, you don't know the game like you think you do.

:hubie:
 

Braman

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
14,427
Reputation
3,296
Daps
57,992
If you believe this, well, you don't know the game like you think you do.

:hubie:

ob.png
 

duncanthetall

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 14, 2012
Messages
45,015
Reputation
4,363
Daps
148,090
Reppin
WHODEY/BIGBLUE/SNOWGANG/MIDNIGHTBOYZ
He’s really raw. It’s not really sleeping on him when he’s barely played. Maybe he develops into a stud. Wouldn’t be surprised with that organization. Good chance he doesn’t though. Will be interesting to see cause son is a hell of an athlete
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
85,177
Reputation
9,397
Daps
230,277
He’s really raw. It’s not really sleeping on him when he’s barely played. Maybe he develops into a stud. Wouldn’t be surprised with that organization. Good chance he doesn’t though. Will be interesting to see cause son is a hell of an athlete
He played 70 games and averaged 17 minutes - that's more than enough games and time on the floor for folks to see his potential. He's a star in the making and the discourse hasn't really reflected that - I understand why that is, I'm just pointing it out. Once he fine-tunes his offensive game, it's a wrap. He has everything else in abundance.

:manny:
 

Robbo

All Star
Joined
Mar 27, 2015
Messages
2,354
Reputation
770
Daps
6,198
He played 70 games and averaged 17 minutes - that's more than enough games and time on the floor for folks to see his potential. He's a star in the making and the discourse hasn't really reflected that - I understand why that is, I'm just pointing it out. Once he fine-tunes his offensive game, it's a wrap. He has everything else in abundance.

:manny:
I think he needs to figure out how to play through things that don't go his way. He had some terrible body language today. I suspect he doesn't do that when playing actual regular season games
 
Top