Why cant black american actors do accents?

Kunty McPhuck

Scust Szn has Returned
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
32,415
Reputation
3,363
Daps
63,220
Reppin
Books and Pencils
it seems as if anytime a black actor is needed for hollywood with an accent they have to look towards english black actors i.e idris for mandela. why is it black american actors limit themselves so much?

Not jsut black actors, the Cac ones too get thrown to the bushes aswell. Its mainly because the British actors are better trained and allowed more creative freedom than their American counterparts are, in the overall training and development process. I'm going to hazard a guess and say that the American actors, see the only way to make yourself a career as an actor is to be on tv/films as alot of their training is camera based so it's geared towards that that. While the Brits do more stage/theatre training, where ad-libing, vocal projection and body language are keys to performing on the stage. i'd say that 95% of the British actors in American TV shows and films have some form of stage trainig, now how many of the American leads can you say that about?
 
Last edited:

TheGodling

Los Ingobernables de Sala de Cine
Joined
May 21, 2013
Messages
20,078
Reputation
5,616
Daps
70,587
Reppin
Rotterdam
idris' accent in the wire was shaky at best. in general, most people faking accents are not particularly good at them unless they are doing a strong accent that can allow for over acting.

:what:

Most people didn't even know Elba was British until they heard him speak in interviews and such.

Anyway, the thing is that many American actors (not just black actors) didn't study acting and really can't step outside their lane. Foreign actors (especially British actors) often tend to have a theater background, so they're more experienced with playing different characters and accents. Even so, you have guys like Don Cheadle and Jeffrey Wright who do have strong backgrounds in acting and it shows in their work, which is a lot more diverse than most black actors.
 

BulletProof

Just a B@stard Living in a Suit
Joined
Dec 22, 2013
Messages
7,349
Reputation
980
Daps
12,281
Reppin
Neck ties and boxing gloves.
Even though I can't stand the dude, Jamie Foxx can.

He can do a mean Pacino too.

No matter what race, some people are born with a better sense of tonality.
 

Roman Brady

Nobody Lives Forever
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,749
Reputation
-1,050
Daps
14,883
Idris Elba is just that good.
i dont get it, i really do not get it, its like i am the only one on the planet that isnt enamored by this guys acting.Yeah stringer bell was dope character and he pulled off the american accent well.Hell i even liked luther but as far as him being a good actor :patrice:and then there is that lesbian looking micheal b jordan its like everyone from wire gets overated to high heaven. Heads swore tristan wild (micheal lee) was going to be the next big thing the he does 90210 and gets exposed :russ:
 

Roman Brady

Nobody Lives Forever
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,749
Reputation
-1,050
Daps
14,883
his parents are Nigerian

did you watch the interviews..

so he's putting up a fake accent in interviews?
many australians did in the 90s to try and lose their real accents :russ: but dude is clearly an american with nigerian parents not exactly what this thread is about
 

Tetris v2.0

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
13,462
Reputation
3,285
Daps
45,629
When has a Black actor had to do an accent aside from an African, Carribean, Southern or "English" type one??

Seems like a bait-ass thread

Why would a Black actor do an Italian, Russian, Australian, Hispanic, German, Jewish etc accent if the vast majority of people from those places are not black? Seems like an odd casting choice
 

Kuwka_Atcha_Ratcha

Superstar
Joined
Jul 17, 2012
Messages
13,684
Reputation
-4,185
Daps
16,493
Reppin
NULL
When has a Black actor had to do an accent aside from an African, Carribean, Southern or "English" type one??

Seems like a bait-ass thread

Why would a Black actor do an Italian, Russian, Australian, Hispanic, German, Jewish etc accent if the vast majority of people from those places are not black? Seems like an odd casting choice
easy... because black people live in all of those countries.

sorry didn't know there was such thing as a jewish accent.

americans cant do any accent where alot of black people live, jamaica, english, welsh, france. etc
 
Top