i come at this from a different angle
i am on my laptop-so this is from memory
there was a study of coping resources
99% sure this was main publication
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8300870
i believe it was five categories
- physical
- spiritual (or "philosophical' for non-religious)
- emotional
- cognitive
- social
we each have our preferences
also in absolute scale- some people have stronger/better/more coping mechanisms than others
for instance, i have above average overall (as measured by a test)
physical = high, social and cognitive = above average
but the other two are pretty weak for me
what does this make me good at??
and where does it leave me vulnrable??
sometimes life hands you a problem that can't be-
exercised away, talked out, or rationalized away
then what?? (for someone like myself)
now imagine the military- enlisted people on frontline
holding a gun, not a support worker
what coping mechanisms would this self-selected group possess?
probably not the stuff needed to cope with ptsd
the same could be said about ex-athletes killing themselves (NFL in particular)
think about it- if you wanted to be as non-suicidal as possible
which of those five coping categories would you choose to draw from??
cognitive coping might even be pro-suicide (in case of debilitating ailments or fear of being tortured to death)
social coping might be problematic if your situation is shameful or criminal in nature
physical coping could also be counterproductve if being in bad health is part of the problem
i am not an expert, have never been suicidal myslef
just some food for thought