Who's The More Successful Franchise:Oakland Raiders Or 49ers

Which franchise is better

  • SF

    Votes: 27 67.5%
  • Oak

    Votes: 13 32.5%

  • Total voters
    40
  • Poll closed .

mitter

All Star
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
3,482
Reputation
-58
Daps
9,458
Reppin
NULL
Interestingly, the 49ers seem to have followed a similar trajectory as the Raiders. Right now, they are where the Raiders were in 2002-03


From 1963-1985, the Raiders were the most successful franchise in pro football. They had 3 Super Bowl wins to go with 1 AFL championship. No team was as consistently good over that stretch. They probably should have won even more Super Bowls, and were a few controversial plays/games away from doing so. Along with their success, their hall-of-fame players, memorable games and moments, and renegade image gave them an unparalleled mystique.

From 1986-2002, the Raiders endured a period of ups and downs, capped by a 3 year run of title contention (2000-2002). They were a very solid playoff team in the early 90s under Art Shell, but that period was sandwiched by two stretches of mediocrity with no playoff appearances. They then had a three year run as serious title contenders, and they got rid of the coach who brought them back (Jon Gruden).


From 1981-1998, the 49ers were the most successful franchise in pro football. They had 5 Super Bowl wins. There were other years they probably were the best team in football, yet came up short (the Montana injury and Craig fumble in 1990, the 1992 loss against the Cowboys). They were so successful, that anything less than a Super Bowl victory was considered a complete failure. The 49ers always seemed to have the best players, and at times it just appeared unfair.

From 1999-2013, the 49ers endured a period of ups and downs, capped by a 3 year run of title contention (2011-2013). They made the playoffs a few times in the early 2000s, but those appearances were sandwiched by stretches of mediocrity with no winning seasons. They then had a three year run as serious title contenders, and they are considering getting rid of the coach who brought them back (Jim Harbaugh).



The parallels are kind of crazy!!!

:ohhh:



You 49ers fans better hope you're not about to enter a decade of perpetual losing ...

:mjcry:
 
Last edited:

dtownreppin214

l'immortale
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
55,567
Reputation
10,511
Daps
191,527
Reppin
Shags & Leathers
Ok, no way I argue this with a bytchboys fan. A team thats relevant because of its owner...and the bears a second tier team? Not at all, bears got a ton of history
lol nobody gives a shyt about the niners. raiders, cowboys, packers, steelers are the dominant fanbases in the nfl. most history, greatest players...if it was a mount rushmore of nfl teams it would be those four.
 

King Kreole

natural blondie like goku
Joined
Mar 8, 2014
Messages
15,207
Reputation
4,453
Daps
42,448
lol nobody gives a shyt about the niners. raiders, cowboys, packers, steelers are the dominant fanbases in the nfl. most history, greatest players...if it was a mount rushmore of nfl teams it would be those four.

:comeon: I dare you to take out Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, Bill Walsh and those 5 superbowls from the game of football and see what happens...
 

dora_da_destroyer

Master Baker
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,013
Reputation
15,912
Daps
266,102
Reppin
Oakland
You 49ers fans better hope you're not about to enter a decade of perpetual losing ...

:mjcry:
thats what it comes down to. It's mostly younger and "new" fans calling for Jim to be gone like ok, make another Jim. But if you were old enough to live through the dark years, you'd know to chill. Real fans understand how much them years hurt. :wow:
 

andre patton

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
2,978
Reputation
970
Daps
8,877
Reppin
SoCal
tc9AE4J.jpg


:sas2:

ARE YOU fukkING SERIOUS?!?!

Gillman_Coaching_Tree.gif


Walsh began his pro coaching career in 1966 as an assistant with the AFL's Oakland Raiders. As a Raider assistant, Walsh was trained in the vertical passing offense favored by Al Davis

http://bayarea.sbnation.com/2011/10...hing-tree-john-madden-bill-walsh-jim-harbaugh

Al Davis BIRTHED Bill Wash. The 49ers OWE most of their success in the 80s to AL DAVIS AND THE OAKLAND RAIDERS. You got the nerve to post up Bill Wash football tree...when Bill Wash is a DESCENDENT of AL DAVIS.

Yall nikkas trippin.

Oakland Raiders the architect for modern day football. 49ers did their thing...but if we EVER wanna talk about HISTORY or IMPACT on the league or INFLUENCE as professional sports organization...the RAIDERS are in the conversation as GOAT.

49ers got superbowl wins, Montana, and Rice. Top 3 NFL franchise. But the Raiders are #1. Cowboys are in the discussion...49ers are not Anybody that actually knows the history of professional football cannot argue against this.
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,063
Reputation
2,506
Daps
63,235
Reppin
The Yay
When the Raiders are winning the whole league is watching, when the 49ers are winning only the Bay cares.
:mjlol: the whole league watches when raiders are winning because they cant believe raiders can actually do that
99% of the league wasnt even born when raiders last won a chip :heh:

kaeps performance against GB in offs had whole board buzzing on here tho :umad:

last time raiders were in the offs you prolly used altavista instead of google and had to post on :flabbynsick: message board off your 56k
and all you got is the bucs sonning your mvp into throwing 5, FIVE picks


I have no ill will towards raiders, but you dudes are making me go off :ufdup:
 
Top