Who's The More Successful Franchise:Oakland Raiders Or 49ers

Which franchise is better

  • SF

    Votes: 27 67.5%
  • Oak

    Votes: 13 32.5%

  • Total voters
    40
  • Poll closed .

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,063
Reputation
2,506
Daps
63,235
Reppin
The Yay
Raiders are more important.
Al Davis Top 5 most influential owners in Sports History
more hall of famers
most wins

best fans
Raiders dominate the state of California... 49er "fans" just have the South Bay and parts of the Valley
Raider Nation bigger worldwide, not even close.
Niner wins = 552
Raiders wins = 435

Niners hall of famers = 22
Raiders hall of famers =22

they should fire you from the bank for failing basic arithmetic
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
17,563
Reputation
-7,340
Daps
64,951
Reppin
Oakland CA
Niner wins = 552
Raiders wins = 435

Niners hall of famers = 22
Raiders hall of famers =22

they should fire you from the bank for failing basic arithmetic

who had the more popular starter jacket in the 90s ? :umad:

more popular logo :umad:

better and larger fan base :umad:

who get's punk'd by Seattle every year :umad:
 

andre patton

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
2,978
Reputation
970
Daps
8,877
Reppin
SoCal
He asked about success...if we're talking impact, culture, historic significance, it's a debate, but success? No, 9ers have a higher winning percentage, more Super Bowl appearances, more Super Bowl wins, and a better playoff record, Niners are more successful

Both "success" and "better" are subjective terms. But if he just wanted to know who has more superbowl wins, then his dumbass coulda just done a google search. I think the question was obviously more in depth than that.

Sports are a business. The NFL is a business. The Raiders have clearly been more successful/better at marketing their product than the 49ers have...which includes their on the field success, historical significance, cultural impact, etc. Even the current coach of the 49ers talked about how the Raiders and Al Davis had a significant role in his development as a coach, and his understanding of the game of football.

If we were strictly talking about on the field success I think it would actually be a good discussion. Niners have more superbowl wins, but I think the Raiders have been to more championship games (NFL and AFL). The Niners have more MVPs, but I think the Raiders have more players in the HOF. I think they're dead even on head to head matchups. :yeshrug:
 

The Devil's Advocate

Call me Dad
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
35,538
Reputation
7,664
Daps
98,592
Reppin
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven
49ers_Super_Bowl_Trophies_at_Family_Day_2009.JPG
:blessed:

how did this even take this long :what:


success in the NFL is about these and these only... there's only ONE team more successful than us
 

King Kreole

natural blondie like goku
Joined
Mar 8, 2014
Messages
15,207
Reputation
4,453
Daps
42,448
I'm literally dying of laughter from this thread.

Yes, the Raiders are an important franchise in the history of this league, and yes, when they were in LA they helped dramatically shape the culture of the league, but come the fukk on, the answer is the San Francisco 49ers. Al Davis is probably the most iconic owner in league history, but he's basically all the Raiders can pin their hat on.

Bill-Walsh-300x208.jpg
Greatest coaching mind in the history of the league.

joe-montana-greatest-qb.jpg
Greatest QB in the history of the league.

628x471.jpg
back to back HOF QBs

Jerry%20Rice%20catch.jpg
Greatest WR/skill player in the history of the league.

20131218__dwightclarkcatch~3_300.JPG
one of the most iconic plays in NFL history

49ers%20family%20day.jpg
legitimate dynasty team

The fact that the Raiders have had probably the worst decade in NFL history means this conversation is a wrap.

:salute:
 

Spiritual Stratocaster

Jesus is KING
Supporter
Joined
Aug 14, 2014
Messages
38,606
Reputation
7,273
Daps
149,545
Raiders are more important.
Al Davis Top 5 most influential owners in Sports History
more hall of famers
most wins
best fans
Raiders dominate the state of California... 49er "fans" just have the South Bay and parts of the Valley
Raider Nation bigger worldwide, not even close.


Who's The More Successful Franchise:Oakland Raiders Or 49ers

:manny:

It's the Niners.
 
Top