Ozymandeas
Veteran
I feel like Jean Grey is more destructive and could probably eviscerate Wanda but, Wanda can manipulate reality and create whole cities and people out of thin air 
Who’s stronger....Wanda (Scarlet Witch) or Jean Grey (Dark Phoenix)?
- Thread starter Ozymandeas
- Start date
I feel like Jean Grey is more destructive and could probably eviscerate Wanda but, Wanda can manipulate reality and create whole cities and people out of thin air 
Bryan Danielson
Jmare007 x Bryan Danielson x JLova = King Ghidorah
The axe murderer
For I am death and I ride on a pale horse
Movies scarlet witch.
Comics..... make sure this doesn't include white phoenix
Comics..... make sure this doesn't include white phoenix
Phoenix dies..Wanda created her own new world. Jean was helpless against Exodus, Stryfe, Sinister, Nate Grey, Magneto. Remember Wanda said No more Phoenix. Simple.
No. @The Doctopian
humminbird
Veteran
I want to say Jean
OmegaK2099
Gettin' It In
Jean
Magic users are ridiculously overpowered in the marvel universe.
...no one wants actual smoke with comic book scarlet witch or dr strange.
...no one wants actual smoke with comic book scarlet witch or dr strange.
comics?
lol
"bye" and everybody said bye and that was it
lol
"bye" and everybody said bye and that was it
Devilinurear
Veteran
It's all made up. Who do you want to win is all that matters
The Lord Doc
Pro
Phoenix is mad inconsistent, but I'd lean towards a Jean who is in control of the Phoenix Force being able to beat Wanda. Thing is, Dark Phoenix Jean wasn't quite that.
Probably the best source to go by is how Wanda and the Phoenix Five were compared in Avengers vs. X-Men. Wanda was able to beat both Magik and Namor when the Phoenix Force was divided between five mutants (they were terrified of her, initially). It wasn't until the Phoenix was split between Scott and Emma 50/50 that either of them had the edge over Wanda in that story (Wanda needed to team up with Hope channeling her power and the Iron Fist to beat Dark Phoenix Cyclops at the end of the event).
That said, Jean was trying to fight the Phoenix's influence over her throughout the Dark Phoenix Saga (Scott and Emma weren't throughout most of Avengers vs. X-Men). I'd think that one of those moments where Jean and Phoenix weren't on the same page would be all that Wanda would need to win.
Last edited:
In my best @MartyMcFly voice: "Whoever the writers want to win." 