Who would you say has the highest ceiling between: Montez Ford, Ricky Starks, & Carmelo Hayes?
- Thread starter ClutchVon
- Start date
Playaz Eyez
Veteran
Ford due to size
Ricky is the most ready made rn.
Melo is the best of the three in terms of in ring stuff.
Ford had the size, athleticism, crossover star appeal and a lot of other tools that make it hard to not have me say it’s him
Melo is the best of the three in terms of in ring stuff.
Ford had the size, athleticism, crossover star appeal and a lot of other tools that make it hard to not have me say it’s him
Finn Baller
Superstar
Melo's height will always work against him to an extent compared to the other two
Starks needs to put on more mass
Montez is the answer
Starks needs to put on more mass
Montez is the answer
Peter Parker
Superstar
Never seen the other two but without the goofy red cup gimmick and terrible entrance music, Montez would be money
Metal Face
Superstar
Montez due to his size
Melo has upside since he's young but isn't as big
Starks is older than them all & not as a big
Melo has upside since he's young but isn't as big
Starks is older than them all & not as a big
This
Dog Based Gremlin
Veteran
RammerJammer
#RollTide #TSC #RiseUp #BullsNation #RIPKobe
Montez has the best look
Melo is the best wrestler
Ricky is the best promo
Melo is the best wrestler
Ricky is the best promo
SpacelySprockets
Veteran
Ricky Starks is good but he benefits from being one of the few newer AEW talents who actually knows how to cut a promo and has charisma which inflates peoples opinion of him, he sometimes gives off miniature Rock vibes which depending on who u ask can be looked at as good or bad, I think he'll be successful long term but with their stacked roster I don't see AEW ever pulling the trigger on him to be THE GUY the way I could see that for a Montez Ford in WWE
Carmelo Hayes is great and he has everything u can ask for from an in ring and promo standpoint but he's very short and although I do think Melo will end up being a star especially with Vince gone, lowkey Trick Williams be outshining him on the mic and I could see Trick being more successful long term
Montez Ford checks off every box you would look for in a star to build around, is every bit as good of a promoer as the other two, puts on great matches, has the size and is already more known and established.. I could legit see him as the face of the company the same way his wife has been built to be, also he's the one who gave her most of her gimmick ideas back when she was a rookie still figuring wrestling out that she still uses to this day
So Montez is my answer
Carmelo Hayes is great and he has everything u can ask for from an in ring and promo standpoint but he's very short and although I do think Melo will end up being a star especially with Vince gone, lowkey Trick Williams be outshining him on the mic and I could see Trick being more successful long term
Montez Ford checks off every box you would look for in a star to build around, is every bit as good of a promoer as the other two, puts on great matches, has the size and is already more known and established.. I could legit see him as the face of the company the same way his wife has been built to be, also he's the one who gave her most of her gimmick ideas back when she was a rookie still figuring wrestling out that she still uses to this day
So Montez is my answer
WhatsGoodTy
Ya feel me
Ricky no debate
Carmelo is the youngest of the three so conceivably has more time to reach greater heights.
That said, AEW could strap the rocket to Ricky Starks RIGHT NOW and he'd be a viable AEW World Champion in no time.
That said, it's Montez. People seem to be ready for that singles run, he's bulked up and looks like a legit star, and we have seen that having a spouse in a top position helps with positioning.
