Who was the worse pick between Mitch Trubisky and Trey Lance?

[Super Cheech]

Lance

 

[duckbutta]

Great question

Low key it might be Mitch just because the 49ers have still been super bowl contenders despite Lance not working out

With how Mahomes and even Watson have turned out, if Fields ends up being a bust, the Bears getting Trubisky may end up being a devastating move for the foreseeable future

IF he a bust?

He won 5 games in two years

 

[prime]

Damn this is actually tough I wanna say lance but no QB really popped yet behind him i think fields will this season but he hasn’t yet as for Mitch two QBs behind him made a all pro team and at deshaun Watson peak he is a all pro Qb and we already know what mahomes is but the 49ers gave up two first round picks and a 3rd while the bears gave up a 3rd and 4th to move up

 

[Big Blue]

Why is there no answer for both???

 

[Po pimp]

Why is there no answer for both???

Because that’s a lame easy way out.

 

[MJ Truth]

Great question

Low key it might be Mitch just because the 49ers have still been super bowl contenders despite Lance not working out

With how Mahomes and even Watson have turned out, if Fields ends up being a bust, the Bears getting Trubisky may end up being a devastating move for the foreseeable future

Hell, if anything that makes the 49ers choice WORSE.

 

[yseJ]

What kinda saves Lance is this though:

Of the QB's selected, the only one that's even debatable that they coulda went after was Fields. None of the other QB's became so good that the Niners guessed horribly wrong on QB. Could they have drafted Parsons and kept their assets and been fine? Sure, but then Jimmy G woulda still been the QB and Niners fans couldn't live with that. Niners fans were so done with Jimmy that management woulda made that trade for Zack fukking Wilson. Watson on the Bears maybe changes everything, including Watson's life.

so done with Jimmy we had to watch an entire year of him after...and another half a year the next year

 

[tremonthustler1]

so done with Jimmy we had to watch an entire year of him after...and another half a year the next year

and every off-season it was a foregone conclusion that he was gonna get cut. It never happened.

 

[Remy LeBreh]

Mitch. I am still tryna figure out what he did or what quality he possessed (aside from skin color of course) that made him worthy of that selection. And they coulda stayed at 3 and grabbed Jordan. Trey at least got potential and as good as the playera draftee after him are can you really justify trading 3 1sts for any of them?

He balled out against Stanford on national television, though I think it was still a loss and Solomon Thomas pushed his shyt in. At the time when Mitch was locked in he threw some nice darts, and he was mobile. I still think he could been decent to good if he didn't get stuck with Fox as a coach, no QB would have developed in Chicago at that time.

 

[Remy LeBreh]

Mitch was starting just last season. Lance probably wasn't going to even on the otherwise loaded 9ers despite being healthy. Watson was the preferred pick with Mitch, and Fields should been selected instead of Trey. Bears gave up a ton just for one slot up, 9ers gave up a ton to jump up quite a bit.

In terms of draft positioning, the Bears is the worse pick. As a whole, I'd say the 9ers had a worse QB scenario collapse. Neither QB had the playtime worthy of their draft numbers, IMO.

Watson tanked the throwing mph test at the combine and that was a massive factor back then... anyone that threw under 55 mph was assumed to be a bust and Watson threw like 54

 

[Brozay]

Mitch. I am still tryna figure out what he did or what quality he possessed (aside from skin color of course) that made him worthy of that selection. And they coulda stayed at 3 and grabbed Jordan. Trey at least got potential and as good as the playera draftee after him are can you really justify trading 3 1sts for any of them?

uhh Trey Lance played one season of Division 1 football

 

[FTBS]

uhh Trey Lance played one season of Division 1 football

Which lets you know it was a total potential play, as he had all the physical tools. Agree or disagree the rationale is clear.

 

[El Bombi]

49ers passed up generational talent for Trey Lance.

 

[feelosofer]

I voted Mitch Trubisky but you know what the 49ers gave up way more and didn't even play him.

With that said Trey still has way more upside.

 

[Regular_P]

Worse PICK was Trubisky, simply because Mahomes went after him and he's the best player in the NFL and probably will be for another decade.

The Trey Lance TRADE was worse. Chicago didn't give up nearly as much as Santa Clara did.