who was more skillfull overall Prime Floyd or Prime Roy?

[Yuzo]

Floyd easy to me.
Roy was a superb athlete, great reflexes but prime Floyd lasted for so long because his boxing mind was superb. Defense was superb. Counter punching was second to none, great footwork, great ring generalship. Floyd was a monster.

roy was a much better counter puncher than floyd mayweather.

 

[Megadeus]

roy was a much better counter puncher than floyd mayweather.

fam, NO ONE was a "much better counterpuncher" than Floyd Mayweather. How would you even gauge a large margin at that level

If anything theyd be even or one would have a slight edge.

 

[Yuzo]

fam, NO ONE was a "much better counterpuncher" than Floyd Mayweather. How would you even gauge a large margin at that level

If anything theyd be even or one would have a slight edge.

i thought floyd was always a little biased to his check hook and his pull counter. but roy threw every counter, and they were all bombs.

 

[R=G]

fam, NO ONE was a "much better counterpuncher" than Floyd Mayweather. How would you even gauge a large margin at that level

If anything theyd be even or one would have a slight edge.

There is no even with prime roy..Castillo had Mayweather frustrated and not able to get off...in his 20s....lol

 

[R=G]

i thought floyd was always a little biased to his check hook and his pull counter. but roy threw every counter, and they were all bombs.

He had Toney missing on the outside..on the inside, countering him on the inside..toney was undefeated and p4p #1...commentators were on edge and didn't want to give Roy full credit until it was obvious he was superior...lol

 

[alpo]

There is no even with prime roy..Castillo had Mayweather frustrated and not able to get off...in his 20s....lol

Come on Breh
So Floyd wasn’t injured?
Damn Breh so can’t get injured
The expectations for being black

 

[thewiseman]

There is no even with prime roy..Castillo had Mayweather frustrated and not able to get off...in his 20s....lol

Montell Griffin had Roy Jones frustrated and he was in his 20s....
Castillo's body of work > Griffin's

Lou De Valle also dropped Roy - when he was in his prime.

 

[R=G]

Come on Breh
So Floyd wasn’t injured?
Damn Breh so can’t get injured
The expectations for being black

I'm just saying...he barely got by...they keep bringing up how Floyd is skilled in his late 30s. We all know this. In his prime..there is no equal to Roy Jones though.

 

[alpo]

I'm just saying...he barely got by...they keep bringing up how Floyd is skilled in his late 30s. We all know this. In his prime..there is no equal to Roy Jones though.

Breh the man beat cas with one arm

that’s not good enough?
Woooooooow

 

[Achille]

Montell Griffin had Roy Jones frustrated and he was in his 20s....
Castillo's body of work > Griffin's

Lou De Valle also dropped Roy - when he was in his prime.

RJJ was winning that whole fight even with that knockdown.

 

[R=G]

Breh the man beat cas with one arm

that’s not good enough?
Woooooooow

It was probably a legit draw or a lost. He got lucky with the scorecards...

 

[R=G]

Montell Griffin had Roy Jones frustrated and he was in his 20s....
Castillo's body of work > Griffin's

Lou De Valle also dropped Roy - when he was in his prime.

Roy had him beat before the DQ

De Valle didn't stand a chance..now go count who lost more rounds in their 20s between Roy and Floyd...loll

 

[Pimp]

Roy had him beat before the DQ

De Valle didn't stand a chance..now go count who lost more rounds in their 20s between Roy and Floyd...loll

i dunno it was close..