What are Peyton's chances of getting MVP?

[NelsonSwagdela]

That is not what he is saying. I've watched him post for years. This is another of his scenarios that he creates. He just said that "he doesn't make up the rules" but this is how it will go. We all admitted that their is media bias, but he is stating his interpretation as if that's the actual criteria of how these things are determined. Even with all the bias that goes in Manning's favor, no one has ever said "you had a better year last year" when determining NFL MVP. The first time I ever saw that garbage used was when Nash won his second NBA mvp.

Fair enough, I just saw one or two post and thought that was what he was implying. Still think manning has the advantage because of his comeback story. But the rest of the stuff you just stated I would agree with you. If I had to wager though right now I would say Manning is in the lead

 

[L&HH]

Peyton's chances just keep getting better and better with each passing week. Really tho all these guys numbers are so close its VERY difficult to choose 1. I'd make the case there needs to be both a co-MVP and co-comeback POY (both Manning and AD, although if I had to pick one it would be Peyton, ppl come back from ACL injuries all the time. Manning on the other hand had a neck injury that ppl speculated he would NEVER comeback from, his team cut him and now he's on a totally new squad, the Broncos barely won their division last season with at the helm and now they about to run away with the shyt and will make noise in the 'offs)

 

[Stone]

lol which goes back to my original point. unless someone else has an unreal season like Rodgers' season last year, Brady 2007, LT 2006, the media and mindless fans will just forcefeed the mvp to Manning, even though their are comparable seasons by other people.[

Forcefeeding?

2003- he got it with McNair. Manning had 1000 more yards and 5 more TDs and a 4.5% advantage in completion percentage. Plus Indy won the division
2004- one of the best seasons ever
2008- missed training camp due to knee surgery Indy had the 31st ranked run game and the O-line continued its decline. One of the worst special teams units as well. Also beat the Chargers head to head and won 4 more games.
2009- new head coach(where is he at now?), no more Marvin Harrison, worst run game in the league(Saints were 6th). Mediocre at best o-line and defense(Saints weren't good on D either but their o-line was much better). Two rookies asked to step in and make significant contributions and went 14-0 while making multiple comebacks. Comparable numbers to Brees even though the Colts were a far worse team offensively. Had the best record in the NFL.

Now if you ask me, Rivers and Brees had as much of a right to the MVP as he did those last two years(Rivers more so than Brees), but forcefeeding is implying that he didn't deserve them at all which can't be said unless you got hate in your blood.

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

@Regular_P u can suck a dikk fakkit. negging me for no reason

awful posting? where was i wrong in anything I said. the fact that so many ppl have manning as the overwhelming frontrunner is proof to what I'm saying

Manning lost to BOTH of the quarterbacks he's in contention with, and there stats are all similar. yet so many more ppl think its Manning and its not even close. fukk outta here with that shyt

 

[yseJ]

@Regular_P u can suck a dikk fakkit. negging me for no reason

awful posting? where was i wrong in anything I said. the fact that so many ppl have manning as the overwhelming frontrunner is proof to what I'm saying

Manning lost to BOTH of the quarterbacks he's in contention with, and there stats are all similar. yet so many more ppl think its Manning and its not even close. fukk outta here with that shyt

@Regular_P is a peyton dikksucking phaggit. dude doesnt understand the concepts of teams or sports, Im convinced

worst than that, he tries to neg people for criticizing people he dikkrides

this dumb piece of shyt has the audacity to say anything about sports while he was proven wrong, multiple times about sports on this board

shyt, he was proven wrong about his OWN TEAM by one of his fellow fans, woo child.

worst of all, he is on a power trip as I hear he is a part of spreadsheet rep crew, and thats why his negreps hit for millions . I dont know whats more pathetic than cycling through reps just to get rep power on this board ? seriously, dumbfukk is prolly jobless and tries to kick knowledge on shyt he has no clue about. its pathetic as hell.

 

[Formerly known as...]

no hate on Manning, but what has he done this season that Brady hasnt?

He doesnt deserve MVP, but comeback player is his for sure.

 

[ASAPbakker]

If his name was Tim Tebow there wouldn't be any argument and he would've been had it on lock

 

[protestor]

no hate on Manning, but what has he done this season that Brady hasnt?

He doesnt deserve MVP, but comeback player is his for sure.

have success on a different team. we all know that brady is a system qb. remember matt casell?

 

[Born2BKing]

no hate on Manning, but what has he done this season that Brady hasnt?

He doesnt deserve MVP, but comeback player is his for sure.

Miss a year with a fukked up neck. Go to a different team with bum ass wide receivers in the craziest altitude in the NFL. Have those Wide Receivers now looking like damn near Pro Bowlers. In the top 5 in the League in almost every statistical category and barely behind Rogers in QBR. 7-3 record through 10 games, riding a 5 game winning streak. All this done without having much of any offseason with this team or knowing if his neck would hold up.

 

[Brozay]

no hate on Manning, but what has he done this season that Brady hasnt?

He doesnt deserve MVP, but comeback player is his for sure.

Oh, and who do you have topping your list?

 

[Thatrogueassdiaz]

With Ryan faltering it's Manning's to lose

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

Miss a year with a fukked up neck. Go to a different team with bum ass wide receivers in the craziest altitude in the NFL. Have those Wide Receivers now looking like damn near Pro Bowlers. In the top 5 in the League in almost every statistical category and barely behind Rogers in QBR. 7-3 record through 10 games, riding a 5 game winning streak. All this done without having much of any offseason with this team or knowing if his neck would hold up.

What does his neck injury have to do with the MVP award?

As usual, people are romanticizing Peyton's performance. He's having a hell of a year, def in the running. I'll wait til the season ends before getting in any deep debates over who deserves it. There's still ample time for guys to separate themselves (either by ascending or faltering)

 

[Born2BKing]

What does his neck injury have to do with the MVP award?

As usual, people are romanticizing Peyton's performance. He's having a hell of a year, def in the running. I'll wait til the season ends before getting in any deep debates over who deserves it. There's still ample time for guys to separate themselves (either by ascending or faltering)

There isn't a more valuable player to their team than Peyton Manning dude. Patriots nor the Packers would go 1-15 if they lost Brady or Rogers.

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

There isn't a more valuable player to their team than Peyton Manning dude. Patriots nor the Packers would go 1-15 if they lost Brady or Rogers.

So that's what the neck injury has to do with the MVP award, huh? Got it.

 

[No1]

There isn't a more valuable player to their team than Peyton Manning dude. Patriots nor the Packers would go 1-15 if they lost Brady or Rogers.

Neither would the Broncos :thiswork:. shyt with their defenses, there's a better argument that the Patriots and Packers would be worse off without Brady and Rodgers. The Broncos won the division last year with the worst starting QB in the league.