Black_Panther_JS

Superstar
Joined
Dec 23, 2015
Messages
11,075
Reputation
930
Daps
33,122


Out of the main shounen MCs he's easily 1 of the weakest

Gon is cool but he was never that strong until he fought Pitou by turning into "Adult Gon' fr

He could probably beat Edward Elric maybe but he's clearly not touching Luffy, Goku, Naruto, Ichigo, Saitama, Jotaro, Josuke, Giorno, 100% Mob, Titan Eren
 

Slic Ric

All Star
Joined
May 12, 2015
Messages
2,464
Reputation
180
Daps
5,944
Reppin
NYC
Reached the episode where Edward and Ein leave the ship. It's the roughest part of every rewatch.

There are few scenes where Edward isn't smiling or making a goofy face in Bebop. But from the moment she sees that hologram of her father, and learns that she does have someone out there looking for her, that carefree disposition is gone. She more or less adopts Faye's crisis of not knowing where she belongs in life. Except that she's so young and has more time to create that path for herself. And she does so with more agency than anyone in Bebop.

tenor.gif



That spinning wheel appears multiple times in this episode. I took it to represent that she is a free spirit. But that wheel can only spin if sustained by wind. With the crew, she is almost always idle inside of the ship while the others get to explore the world and do bounties. Often shown to be bored (with Ein), not allowed to do much for herself, though she is capable (as seen in Mushroom Samba where she and Ein solo a bounty). Ed gives that wheel to Spike before she leaves. And either Spike or Jet plant it onto the helm of the ship as it spins at the end of the episode.

Spike and Jet see Edward, Faye down after they return from the orphanage. They know something is wrong. But instead of asking them, maybe offering some sort of encouragement, they ignore them.

m8r0K7l.png

s5ljABV.png

Then when they leave the ship, they're pissed. Those two stuffing eggs down their throats with frowned faces, zero communication, underlines so much about them as characters and their individual struggles (particularly Jet, who has lost relationships b/c of a lack of communication). They obviously care, but are too prideful to outright show that they care.

qMTBEV3.png

lWbtdZU.png

4eccbOo.png

They still set up a bowl for Ed, even though they know she's left. Faye too though they swear to dislike her. And Ein, who was considered a burden by Spike in episode 2. That was the only family they had left and lost it all in one day, though Faye does return later.

It is Ein who shows the most compassion on that ship for the wellbeing of Ed, and it's an awesome moment when he decides to go with her. Though not before looking back at the ship twice, nearly turning around. In general Ein the most conscious character in Bebop, shown to understand situations better than any other human.

r2meJj7.png

o2bjI7C.png

tm9kavb.png

UB8bcUV.png

yQo9MyG.png

p0obqS6.png

After the 2nd Vicious encounter, Ed asks Faye what happened in the arc with she and Ed left behind. Faye says she'll tell her when she's older. Too young to know what goes on in the world outside of the ship. So it's appropriate that Ed gets to find out what the world is like for herself, maybe later to meet Faye and Jet again and act as their peer rather than an oft dismissed underling.

There's voice actor commentary on the version I'm using. They give their thoughts on the episode in a casual manner. The staff really loved Ed and what she represented to Bebop. They were very emotional about her departure. The show treats her and Ein with really no less respect than Spike, Jet or Faye, which is probably the reason that most Bebop viewers appreciate those characters and respond as strongly to their departure.
Think its time to rewatch Bebop as a full fledge adult, last time I watched it was around 18 & there were probably stuff I didn't get I'd love now
 

LordDeathwatch

Valar Morghulis
Supporter
Joined
Feb 10, 2017
Messages
14,841
Reputation
12,509
Daps
73,828
Reppin
Baltimore, MD / Charlotte, NC
Out of the main shounen MCs he's easily 1 of the weakest

Gon is cool but he was never that strong until he fought Pitou by turning into "Adult Gon' fr

He could probably beat Edward Elric maybe but he's clearly not touching Luffy, Goku, Naruto, Ichigo, Saitama, Jotaro, Josuke, Giorno, 100% Mob, Titan Eren

The Negs that @42 Monks alone will drop on this. :picard:
 

Kenny West

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
25,171
Reputation
6,098
Daps
92,726
Reppin
NULL

This is true. Im sure Togashi had an ambitious development arc for Gon but he doesnt have the work ethic to bring that completely to fruition. His character arc is still in that "ant in tornado" phase as Luffy in the Maineford arc 10 years ago and the most fun feats/fights are from the rest of the cast. It doesn't help that Gon's powers are kinda ass and uninspired.

Plus series with technical smart fights tend to have weaker characters.:yeshrug:
 
Last edited:

TobiOT

Veteran
Joined
Jan 29, 2017
Messages
31,224
Reputation
3,323
Daps
77,857
Reppin
East London
Out of the main shounen MCs he's easily 1 of the weakest

Gon is cool but he was never that strong until he fought Pitou by turning into "Adult Gon' fr

He could probably beat Edward Elric maybe but he's clearly not touching Luffy, Goku, Naruto, Ichigo, Saitama, Jotaro, Josuke, Giorno, 100% Mob, Titan Eren
Goku is in a league of his own. :russ:
 

Arris

Superstar
Joined
Sep 11, 2013
Messages
8,893
Reputation
2,684
Daps
32,933
Reppin
Cleveland
the way MAPPA is handling jujutsu kaisen is making me even more hyped for attack on titan :noah:

they are being very faithful/respectful to the manga and the add ins they've been doing to put their mark on the show have been very well done so far. whoever the director is, is obviously a fan of the source material
 

Consumed

Superstar
Joined
May 6, 2015
Messages
5,989
Reputation
1,381
Daps
16,107
Think its time to rewatch Bebop as a full fledge adult, last time I watched it was around 18 & there were probably stuff I didn't get I'd love now

that was my experience. didn’t care about it on toonami (nor Ghost in the shell). Watched again years later as an adult and appreciated the themes.
 

42 Monks

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 20, 2014
Messages
56,797
Reputation
9,673
Daps
210,923
Reppin
Carolina
the way MAPPA is handling jujutsu kaisen is making me even more hyped for attack on titan :noah:

they are being very faithful/respectful to the manga and the add ins they've been doing to put their mark on the show have been very well done so far. whoever the director is, is obviously a fan of the source material
all signs point to attack on titan being a trainwreck
 
Top