VOTE or DIE: Years later. How do we view Red Dead Redemption 2?

[Lord Beasley]

and if you look at that article it clearly says red dead revolver got mixed reviews. while RDR and RDR2 both received critical acclaim.
and as a person who completed all three game multiple times each, it was well warranted reactions for all three.
i can understand if you feel like you have an outlier opinion. but you here acting like its consensus that revolveer is the best game in the series

that doesn't mean they couldn't remake it. i had more fun playing Revolver back in the day than redemption, that's not no outlier opinion i've felt this way since RDR1 dropped. i never once said "i think they should've remade it because it was a better reviewed a received game" chill out

and the RDR1 remake/remaster/whatever hasn't been received well, so wtf is your point?

 

[Jasonmask]

I was let down. Story was predictable miles away gameplay was inferior to the first one imo

 

[Black Mamba]

 

[Redguard]

Good points. The only thing that really felt forced to me was how kind everybody in Dutch's gang was to Tilly, Charles, and Lenny (R.I.P.).
In a group full of rednecks, nobody showed any ?
That part didn't pass the realism test.

Micah did. He called Charles and Lenny darkies.

 

[Rollie Forbes]

Micah did. He called Charles and Lenny darkies.

You're right.
Fukk Micah.