TSC Evaluation #50: The Undertaker

[Superkick Party]

The OG Mark for himself Mr. Mark Calaway

-Mic work/promos: 7.3

-Personality/gimmicks: 8.7

-Ring work (along with some of your favorite matches/feuds): Ring work before 2005 a 6, ring work 2005-2013 a solid 8.7
Favorite Feuds: Taker vs Punk WM 29
Taker vs Batista in 2007
Taker vs Edge in 2008
Taker vs HHH in 2012
Taker vs Shawn in 2009
-Overall rating: 9

 

[Breh Obama]

nikkas really did an evaluation for nikkas like Buff Bagwell, Vader, and Scott Steiner before the Undertaker?

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

What would you guys say is Undertaker's best year in terms of overall performance? I remember listening to Prichard's 93-94 run for Taker and almost passed out in the middle of traffic with how boring it was.

Is there a definitive Undertaker year?

Edit - I'm a work, sorry, but how you compare the careers of Taker and Vader?

Undertaker was signficantly more successful than vader, made way more money, and was imo a much better worker, there isnt much of a comparison to me. His best years are from mania 20-26 when he first ditched biketiker and had classic mania matches as well as winning the title vs edge in their great feud, and two A+ matches vs hbk. If you want more specific, mania 24-26. He was still relatively agile for a big guy, had a better moveset than before (added hells gate submission, and last ride finisher), and his OPPONENTS were stepping up too.

 

[El Guapo]

Everything after the Hell in a Cell in 2015 with Brock has been and there's been some bad spots in his career but it's an easy 10.

 

[patscorpio]

nikkas really did an evaluation for nikkas like Buff Bagwell, Vader, and Scott Steiner before the Undertaker?

Bruh ain't nothing wrong with Scott or Vader before Taker

I'll give you Bagwell

 

[Nero Christ]

10 for Taker. He has his flaws like every other wrestler but there is no denying his place as a legend as well as his standing in wrestling. He is wrestling and there aren't too many names people will bring up before his when you ask them to name wrestlers.

 

[Breh Obama]

Bruh ain't nothing wrong with Scott or Vader before Taker

I'll give you Bagwell

DLo Brown tho?

 

[Silkk]

10

If the lights went out on ANY show tomorrow and his first gong sound hit...any true pro wrestling fan would mark out

Man that shyt could happen while i'm driving at 80mph on the interstate and I would mark out

 

[Chris Cool]

mic work: 6 was gonna give 8 but minus 2 for big show snakeskin boots promo.

ring work:8 before like 5 after

gimmicks -10

overall - 9

 

[Vic Damone. Jr]

10 Glad I had the chance to see him in person at a live RAW event before WM30. Thought he wasn't gonna be there but wrestling news sites announced his upcoming dates for RAW Wanted to see Brock too but

 

[Francis White]

9.5
Mic work 9 short but effective
In ring skill . 9.5 for a big man best striker in WWE.
Best matches : HBK, Kurt Angle and Brock.
All time great and hall of famer.
The man put on classic matches for decades and with HBK help immortalized himself as big match man at mania.

 

[mrken12]

nikkas really did an evaluation for nikkas like Buff Bagwell, Vader, and Scott Steiner before the Undertaker?

Undertaker was still an active wrestler early in this series. Besides thread #50 is a special milestone so why not save it for a special legend like The Undertaker?

 

[Starboy52]

10.

The GOAT Gimmick, producing God tier Blood Feuds & moments for close to 30 years.

 

[OVER]

Just gave him a 10

 

[Breh Obama]

Undertaker was still an active wrestler early in this series. Besides thread #50 is a special milestone so why not save it for a special legend like The Undertaker?