TSC Evaluation #44: Edge
- Thread starter mrken12
- Start date
Here Comes the Pain
Superstar
One of the protected superstars the wwe has ever produced & that's saying something.
Christian was better btw, but we know how politics work.:edgelook:
He gets a solid 7 only because he had moments of greatness in the early stages of his rated R gimmick( dismantled every fiber of matt Hardy's existence) & his tag team stint with christian.:edgewise:
Christian was better btw, but we know how politics work.:edgelook:
He gets a solid 7 only because he had moments of greatness in the early stages of his rated R gimmick( dismantled every fiber of matt Hardy's existence) & his tag team stint with christian.:edgewise:
I just didn't want it to turn into one of "those" threads.Got to keep it a stack
I dont know why anyone would revisit his goofy CAC sh1t with Christian again now. If you laughed when you were 8, OK.
Ring- 8. He didnt do a lot of cool looking moves or make things look real, but he always found a way to put on a good show in big matches. The tag run with Mysterio resulted in some actual GOAT level matches imo. Plus the Cena feud. He was a great worker. It might be me personally not liking him keeping him from a 9.
Mic- 7. Good, but not outstanding. He sometimes overdid it with the "wrestlingness" of his promos and it didnt fit with his character like it did for others. Still good though.
Charisma/Star Power- 7, his entrance/valets/etc help him a lot here. He doesn't necessarily ace the Walmart Test brother, but doesnt bomb it, his mic skills arent outstanding, but the other things help him out here. He also drew well with that Cena feud. He didnt reinvent himself really in his last 5 years, and I think it wouldve helped.
Overall- 7. Close to an 8.
Ring- 8. He didnt do a lot of cool looking moves or make things look real, but he always found a way to put on a good show in big matches. The tag run with Mysterio resulted in some actual GOAT level matches imo. Plus the Cena feud. He was a great worker. It might be me personally not liking him keeping him from a 9.
Mic- 7. Good, but not outstanding. He sometimes overdid it with the "wrestlingness" of his promos and it didnt fit with his character like it did for others. Still good though.
Charisma/Star Power- 7, his entrance/valets/etc help him a lot here. He doesn't necessarily ace the Walmart Test brother, but doesnt bomb it, his mic skills arent outstanding, but the other things help him out here. He also drew well with that Cena feud. He didnt reinvent himself really in his last 5 years, and I think it wouldve helped.
Overall- 7. Close to an 8.
8 and it's more of a rounding up to 8. Was part of one of the great tag feuds and matches. Went singles and was successful....
However, he was a champion stat padder who no real memorable reigns and if he wasn't wrestling in a gimmick match then the match was kinda just there
Let Rick The Model Martel get an Edge push and Martel would've got 9s out of y'all
However, he was a champion stat padder who no real memorable reigns and if he wasn't wrestling in a gimmick match then the match was kinda just there
Let Rick The Model Martel get an Edge push and Martel would've got 9s out of y'all
Pinyapplesuckas
He's A Good Man
4/10
not a fan
not a fan
Some where between an 8 And 9, I'm in a generous mood so I'll give him a 9. As pointed out, he was versatile on the mic, good in the ring, has classic matches
ALTRUISM
"My enemy is a notion, not a nation."
An 8 for this fukkery alone...
Had a younger breh like
Unfortunately had my mom like
Outside of that, he was solid wrestler to watch in all fronts whether it be matches, segments, promos, etc.
Had a younger breh like
Unfortunately had my mom like
Outside of that, he was solid wrestler to watch in all fronts whether it be matches, segments, promos, etc.
Last edited:
He was a 7.
Amor fati
Superstar
His Rated R gimmick was off the damn chain, I literally hated the dude every time him and his ex how would pop up on TV., His mic and promo skills is an 8. My jaw opened when I saw Edge on ECW one night stand dry humping Tommy's girl, dude then spears her and pins her in a sex position.
Amor fati
Superstar
5. 
-garbage CAW moveset(his spear is a joke)
-Christian was more versatile
-robotic talker...borderline bad
-too many world title reigns that could have gone to others
Yeah, I just don't like dude. I've hated his entire career. I never saw they appeal in him.
-garbage CAW moveset(his spear is a joke)
-Christian was more versatile
-robotic talker...borderline bad
-too many world title reigns that could have gone to others
Yeah, I just don't like dude. I've hated his entire career. I never saw they appeal in him.
DamienWayne
Superstar
-Mic work/promos- 9 one of the more believable speakers in the ruthless aggression era. had a great connection with the crowd even above the big three at the time cena orton and batista.
-Personality/gimmicks- 10 ultimate opportunist , the rated r superstar, master manipulator. he perfected the sneaky heel gimmick that the miz is running with. even when he was the physically weaker heel u always knew he could pull a win by some kind of trick. so much charisma, he was a heel that that getting babyface pops. that theme song
-Ring work - 8. what he lacked in technical skills, he made up in ring IQ . He had a big part in making batista cena and il even say the undertaker as big as they were. his feud with taker in 06 was one of takers last good ones. live sex show, first to cash in MITB. i will NEVER forget when he came out at the end of new years revolution and cashed in. legendary moment.
-Overall rating 10. even tho his career ended early he still had a legendary career. the company would be different if he were still in it. Edge is the blueprint of a wwe wrestler.
-Personality/gimmicks- 10 ultimate opportunist , the rated r superstar, master manipulator. he perfected the sneaky heel gimmick that the miz is running with. even when he was the physically weaker heel u always knew he could pull a win by some kind of trick. so much charisma, he was a heel that that getting babyface pops. that theme song
-Ring work - 8. what he lacked in technical skills, he made up in ring IQ . He had a big part in making batista cena and il even say the undertaker as big as they were. his feud with taker in 06 was one of takers last good ones. live sex show, first to cash in MITB. i will NEVER forget when he came out at the end of new years revolution and cashed in. legendary moment.
-Overall rating 10. even tho his career ended early he still had a legendary career. the company would be different if he were still in it. Edge is the blueprint of a wwe wrestler.
DamienWayne
Superstar
literally shocked at the Edge hate. i would have never thought he had people who didnt like him. i see some bias in here. That Orton thread gonna be LEGENDARY for the fukkery