Not according to the Halo community. That was the game that split the fanbase in a major way. I call it the great Halo schism.
for the record i love the Reach campaign n custom games but it was def a lil too diff n weird comin from 3 as far as competitive multi
When you say Halo community you mean a handful of people
Reach campaign is the best campaign in any Halo imo. And the multiplayer was best in class at the time.
Halo 4 was trash but mainly because of the levels, I didn't mind the new abilities.
Halo 5 was damn near perfect online imo but it was different and I get it that ppl who don't wanna stop playing Halo 1,2 wouldn't like it.
I feel like Halo infinite is Halo 3 and 5 combined to make what Halo 4 should have became. So if the campaign can be anything close to Halo reach? Then this will be the best game ever, period.