NFL playoff bracket predictions: Bill Barnwell picks every winner, including the Super Bowl score
I would love to tell you that there are spoilers below for the 2020 NFL playoffs, but I know that's not true. It's incredibly difficult to predict how 13 NFL games will go. Last season, three of the four teams that were favored to win in the wild-card round lost. The world was waiting for a Ravens-Chiefs battle in the AFC Championship Game, but Baltimore was easily dispatched by Tennessee in the divisional round. If you had a perfect playoff bracket by the time the Chiefs beat the 49ers in Miami, well, you earned it.
This year as my preview for the playoffs, I'm going to lay out the 13-game bracket and predict the winners, all the way to Super Bowl LV. It will almost definitely be wrong and ruined by the time we get through the three opening games on Saturday, which is fine. Hopefully, there's insight in here that will give you stuff to look for in advance of the games, regardless of how the results actually go.
NFC wild-card weekend
(7) Chicago Bears at (2) New Orleans Saints
The four-game stretch from Bears quarterback Mitchell Trubisky that set the hearts of NFL executives aflutter in December came against the teams ranked 14th (Vikings), 29th (Texans), 31st (Jaguars), and 32nd (Lions) in defensive DVOA. In the game against the Vikings, Trubisky was 15-of-21 passing for 202 yards with a touchdown and a pick. A late Trubisky fumble cost Chicago the game against the Lions. The fourth-year passer started and ended his run with games against the Packers, a team with a competent pass defense that requires the other team to throw to stay in the game. Trubisky averaged 5.6 yards per attempt, threw three interceptions and fumbled three times in those two games.
The Saints rank third in pass defense DVOA and second against the run, so chances are that running back David Montgomery won't be around to bail out Trubisky. The Bears have upped his play-action rate and gotten him on the edge more frequently during this most recent stretch as a starter, but the Saints have one of the postseason's most devastating edge combinations in Cameron Jordan and Trey Hendrickson. If Trubisky beats the Saints in New Orleans with a big game, the Bears might sign him to an extension on the 50-yard line in the Superdome. Prediction: Saints 31, Bears 10.
(6) Los Angeles Rams at (3) Seattle Seahawks
It's unclear whether the Rams will be able to call upon quarterback Jared Goff in this game, a move that would open up a second consecutive start for AAF star John Wolford. The 25-year-old was impressive as a scrambler against Arizona in Week 17, and after an interception on his first pass, he was careful enough with the football to avoid the traps the Cardinals tried to set for him in coverage. He also left multiple touchdowns on the field with underthrows or misses. The Rams expect to get back top receiver Cooper Kupp and star left tackle Andrew Whitworth, but running back Cam Akers wasn't effective last week in his return from a high ankle sprain.
Whether it's a compromised Goff or the inexperienced Wolford, the Seahawks have been dominating overmatched quarterbacks on defense over the past six weeks. They've gone 5-1 over that stretch while holding Carson Wentz, Colt McCoy, Sam Darnold, Dwayne Haskins, Goff and Nick Mullens to a league-best 1.29 points per possession. The Rams are second over that time frame, but as we saw in Week 16, Seattle might not need many points to win this one. Receiver Tyler Lockett had his biggest game in more than two months in Week 17, and with cornerback Jalen Ramsey expected to shadow DK Metcalf, another 90-yard performance could be what gets Seattle through to the next round. Prediction: Seahawks 24, Rams 10.
(5) Tampa Bay Buccaneers at (4) Washington Football Team
Nobody is likely to pick a 7-9 team to win a playoff game, but that's short-sighted. Remember what happened the last time a team with a losing record made it to the playoffs? The 7-9 Seahawks were 10-point underdogs at home against the 11-5 Saints, who had beat them by 15 points during the regular season. Didn't matter. Seattle held New Orleans to field goals three times in seven red zone trips and hit two long touchdown passes from Matt Hasselbeck before sealing a 41-36 win with the one thing you do remember from that game, the Beastquake. Those Seahawks weren't a great team all season, but they were up to the task for one week.
Compared to that Saints-Seahawks game, it's much easier to construct a scenario in which Jack Del Rio's Washington defense gives the Buccaneers trouble. The book on frustrating quarterback Tom Brady has been clear for more than a decade now: get pressure, preferably without having to blitz. Brady ranks fifth in the league in QBR this season when opposing defenses don't get pressure on him. When they do get pressure? Brady's QBR is tied with Andy Dalton and Nick Mullens at 31st. Over the last six weeks, defensive end Chase Young & Co. are sixth in the league in pressure rate and third-best at creating pressure without blitzing.
Alex Smith's mobility is severely compromised. I'd expect Tampa Bay defensive coordinator Todd Bowles to dial up A-gap pressure with his linebackers and defensive backs to try to force Smith out of the pocket while making Washington try to run into his top-ranked rush defense. Unless Washington can create 2-plus turnovers with its defense and special teams, I don't think it can do enough on offense to win. Prediction: Buccaneers 17, Washington 7.
AFC wild-card weekend
(7) Indianapolis Colts at (2) Buffalo Bills
The Colts will try to pull off an upset, presumably, by holding onto the football with their running game and keeping quarterback Josh Allen off the field. Jonathan Taylor is fully entrenched as Indy's primary back and ran for 253 yards last week, but that was against the Jaguars. Owing to a better run defense and their game scripts, the Bills haven't allowed a 100-yard rusher since Week 10. Allen deservedly has gotten plenty of attention, but the Buffalo defense has quietly gotten back on track since the team's Week 11 bye; it has improved from 22nd in defensive EPA per play before the bye to the fourth-best mark in football afterward.
Colts defensive coordinator Matt Eberflus has a sound, solid defense, but it might not match up well against Allen. The Colts have the fourth-best QBR allowed in the league when they get quarterbacks to throw within 2.5 seconds, but they fall to 29th when the quarterback gets more than 2.5 seconds to pick apart their zones. Allen ranks second in the league this season in completions and first in passing yards after holding the ball for more than 2.5 seconds. I'm just not sure I trust quarterback Philip Rivers' chances of holding up in a shootout if this game turns into one. Prediction: Bills 30, Colts 20.
(6) Cleveland Browns at (3) Pittsburgh Steelers
The Browns were already the weakest team in the playoff field, finishing the season 18th in DVOA while being outscored by their opponents. Their team has further been torn apart by positive COVID-19 tests, with multiple players and now coach Kevin Stefanski out for Sunday's game. The Steelers come into Sunday's game as well-rested as they've been since the opener.
Cleveland's play-action scheme doesn't match up well against the Steelers, whose QBR against play-action passes is 34 points better than any other team in football. Pittsburgh's biggest win of the season came at home against Cleveland in Week 6, and while the Browns responded with a 24-22 victory last week, that win came against backup quarterback Mason Rudolph and with many of Pittsburgh's stars inactive. The Browns have made huge strides in 2020, but their season ends here. Prediction: Steelers 34, Browns 7.