The Official Criterion Collection Thread

Roaden Polynice

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
14,346
Reputation
236
Daps
18,941
Gimme Shelter from 1970

I thought that this was going to be a straightforward concert film. I've read that it's the best rock and roll film ever made. Nuh uh I said, Stop Making Sense is the greatest concert film of all time, Gimme Shelter and The Last Waltz be damned. Little did I know that Gimme Shelter is entirely different and much more complex than a mere concert, and Stop Making Sense is the straightforward concert film.

I read, that Mick Jagger understandably said that once he heard the news that Meredith Hunter was killed during The Rolling Stones’ set, his thoughts didn’t immediately begin to wander about the end of an era. It is an irresistible thought though, given the film produced out of the Stones’ final days on their North American tour. It is a film of reticence and simply filming things as they are. The band members rarely ever talk, and, instead has, mostly Mick, watching the film with the audience and reflecting back on the events that occurred. This serves as a sort of self-reflection, with his subtle reactions to what he’s watching, that ends up saying more than any extended interviews could have revealed.

It is a genuinely harrowing concert experience though. One marked by brutality, drugs, audience members dancing in the most irritating fashion they possibly could, floppy t*ts, long hair, white liberals, inexplicably babies, pimps, gang members, questionable wardrobe decisions, curtailed grooming regiments and dogs. In short every stereotype of the 60’s that one could, in one paragraph on any given night, think of.

With the film providing these images, the indelible theme of the finality of a mentality or a way of life incessantly pops up. This is one work about the end of the 60s that I have been thinking about (the others: Withnail and I and Mad Men). There was something special and simple about that time that simultaneously is infinitely difficult to articulate. Mad Men does to an extent, but the show is so layered and focuses on several things at once that the theme often gets drowned out. Withnail and I finds the titular characters in the final days of 1969 plunged in a haze of drugs and booze with Danny the drug dealer musing on the end of the 60’s labeling London as a country coming down from its trip. Danny, I think, out of these three works has the best commentary on the end of the decade. “If you're hanging onto a rising balloon, you're presented with a difficult decision - let go before it's too late or hang on and keep getting higher, posing the question: how long can you keep a grip on the rope? They're selling hippie wigs in Woolworths, man. The greatest decade in the history of mankind is over. And as Presuming Ed here has so consistently pointed out, we have failed to paint it black.” Indeed. It’s the end of the party, the confetti is being swept, the streamers are thrown out, trim your hair, and get out before you can because life is changing rapidly. I’m assuming that it was a striking wake up call for the world at the time. A large-scale and collective growing up and coming to their senses. And the final scenes of Gimme Shelter showing the morning after the concert with people packing up and leaving, and Mick shutting off the film machine (I was born in 1989, fukk off) is a fitting image to round out a fascinating decade in history.
 

Nature's Fury

addicts of drugs not yet synthesized
Joined
Jun 26, 2014
Messages
4,110
Reputation
850
Daps
15,548
finally signed up just for this thread...just got Hulu Plus and been killin' the Criterion section and was looking for more to run through...

my recommendations:

La Haine - one of my favorite movies...only about 90 mins long so a short shot, but packs a punch...a French crime movie with strong hip hop roots...i think it was Vincent Cassel's first movie...either way, one of the best movies i've ever seen and i suggest everyone to run through it...

The Seventh Seal - heard a few people saying they couldn't get through it, but it's definitely worth it...i'm a huge fan of Ingmar Bergman because i love his views on religion and the human experience...i still have a few more of his movies to peep, but i think aside from Wild Strawberries, this was my favorite one...

Wild Strawberries - my favorite Ingmar Bergman flick, period...

Z - seen this a while back and don't remember it exactly, but remember loving it...made by Costa Gavras, Romain Gavras' (MIA's Born Free and Bad Girls video, Kanye and Jay's No Church In The Wild, Justice's Stress videos) father...

i guess i can recommend a few more after scrolling through the list and seeing what all is on there...this is gonna keep me occupied all summer haha...

gonna check out Diabolique tonight...adding The Wages of War and Sorcerer to the queue...will check back with my opinion later...
 

Nature's Fury

addicts of drugs not yet synthesized
Joined
Jun 26, 2014
Messages
4,110
Reputation
850
Daps
15,548
just peeped Wages of Fear...i'm on the train with everybody else who hated the ending...rest of the movie was really good tho...Diabolique was piff too...even tho the ending caught me by surprised, i thought it was done sloppily...also peeped Ugetsu...pretty good movie, but kinda ridiculous...

gonna watch a few more a random this weekend since i ain't doin shyt else...
 

FlyRy

Superstar
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
30,692
Reputation
3,125
Daps
62,183
finally signed up just for this thread...just got Hulu Plus and been killin' the Criterion section and was looking for more to run through...

my recommendations:

La Haine - one of my favorite movies...only about 90 mins long so a short shot, but packs a punch...a French crime movie with strong hip hop roots...i think it was Vincent Cassel's first movie...either way, one of the best movies i've ever seen and i suggest everyone to run through it...

The Seventh Seal - heard a few people saying they couldn't get through it, but it's definitely worth it...i'm a huge fan of Ingmar Bergman because i love his views on religion and the human experience...i still have a few more of his movies to peep, but i think aside from Wild Strawberries, this was my favorite one...

Wild Strawberries - my favorite Ingmar Bergman flick, period...

Z - seen this a while back and don't remember it exactly, but remember loving it...made by Costa Gavras, Romain Gavras' (MIA's Born Free and Bad Girls video, Kanye and Jay's No Church In The Wild, Justice's Stress videos) father...

i guess i can recommend a few more after scrolling through the list and seeing what all is on there...this is gonna keep me occupied all summer haha...

gonna check out Diabolique tonight...adding The Wages of War and Sorcerer to the queue...will check back with my opinion later...
i didnt know they had other bergmans on there. I just added them to my queue. :jawalrus:

you also just named about 5 movies on my imdb top 250 challenge

my girl and i have been spending so much more time on hulu plus than netflix lately because of these flicks.
 

StraxStrax

I'm selling these fine leather jackets
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
8,807
Reputation
880
Daps
16,699
C'mon guys 400 blows is the best Truffaut movie
 

Cal Cutta

Balthazar
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
1,246
Reputation
447
Daps
3,888
Reppin
NULL
No question The 400 Blows is the best Truffaut. Shoot the Piano Player is also great, though.

La Haine is a classic.

Persona is my favorite Bergman film. The Virgin Spring is very underrated Bergman. His "Chamber Trilogy" (boxet of "Through a Glass Darkly", "Winter Light", and "The Silence"), I'd consider that required viewing. Not really a fan of his work before "The Seventh Seal".
 

FlyRy

Superstar
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
30,692
Reputation
3,125
Daps
62,183
Finally finished The wages of fear. Loved it.

the movie kind of reminded me of the Treasure of the Sierra Madre and Yves montand reminded me of a taller humphrey bogart.
 

FlyRy

Superstar
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
30,692
Reputation
3,125
Daps
62,183
Now watch Sorcerer.

It's probably the best original-remake pairing of films I can think of....
you seen a lot of films from the 20s and 30s? I just realized i've seen hardly anything from the 20s and only a handful of late 30s films
 

HHR

Do what you love
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
19,021
Reputation
1,622
Daps
39,388
you seen a lot of films from the 20s and 30s? I just realized i've seen hardly anything from the 20s and only a handful of late 30s films

Not much outside of a handful of Chaplin's classics and some of Keaton's work.
 

Nature's Fury

addicts of drugs not yet synthesized
Joined
Jun 26, 2014
Messages
4,110
Reputation
850
Daps
15,548
No question The 400 Blows is the best Truffaut. Shoot the Piano Player is also great, though.

La Haine is a classic.

Persona is my favorite Bergman film. The Virgin Spring is very underrated Bergman. His "Chamber Trilogy" (boxet of "Through a Glass Darkly", "Winter Light", and "The Silence"), I'd consider that required viewing. Not really a fan of his work before "The Seventh Seal".

lotta people biggin up 400 Blows...i saw it a while back and don't really remember it, but don't remember being that impressed...i guess i'll peep it again later this week...i had Shoot The Piano Player on the queue...

La Haine is definitely a classic...rewatched it this weekend just because...

Feel you on the Bergman thing...i watched a few of his pre-Seventh Seal flicks during my formative years and ALMOST gave up on him...glad i didn't...from what you posted I only seen The Virgin Spring and Through A Glass Darkly...Persona the movie without words, right???
 
Top