When I was younger, we had a VHS in my house for this horror movie. I used to throw it on and have to turn it off after 10 or 15 minutes. It must have taken me 4 or 5 sit downs to get through it the first time. Last night, I realized it was on Amazon Prime and thought I'd check if a movie that terrified me at like 10 years old, still held up...Clive Barker's sleeper Lord of Illusions.
Lord of Illusions opens with a raid on a cult. A magician (Nicks) with real powers is confronted by some of his former acolytes (led by Swann) and killed with a seal placed over his face (this ten minute intro was enough to make me stop watching my first couple of tries). From there the movie flashes forward to a detective that is tracking down a series of murders. It looks like the cult's leftover members are killing the group that took out Nicks.
So the main plot follows a detective who has to find out who the killers are and what they're really after while trying to find and save Swann and his crew. It's a mystery with grizzly murders and an added layer in that most of the principle characters are magicians who have mastered trickery. The violence is visceral and we get brought into the "behind the scenes" world of stage magicians while the detective learns about real and fake magic.
So what works? The world feels realized; a lot of characters barely get introduced to us but have enough characterization that they feel fully fleshed out. The murders are pretty ghastly throughout the movie, Clive Barker's torture porn before torture porn blew up. The magic has some really dope stand out moments where powers cause pretty wild visuals too.
What doesn't work? Well, this is 1995 effects and it shows with a majority of the "magic" we witness. That might have looked impressive when I was younger, but a decent chunk of it looks so phony that I can't believe 10 year old me punked out. While a lot of characters have some depth, the actual plot is pretty straight forward. There are a couple of small twists but nothing too shocking. It's kinda just a tale of "detective tracks lead, baddies beat him to a spot, he chases the baddies, rinse and repeat." The elements of magic and horror are what help it rise above that simple formula.
Overall...this is one that I'm kinda surprised survived the torture porn run without getting a remake. It's a great premise that would get a big boost from upgraded effects and modern gritty sentiments. Nicks, Swann and Butterfield are all really memorable characters and the exploration of magicians has worked in other genres. It's a good movie that could be a lot scarier had the effects held up.