Season 2 definitely felt like they were going for broke because they didn't feel too secure that they would get a third season but I still enjoyed.I liked both seasons too!.. but I guess we were the only few that did.. disappointed that it didn't get renewed. I liked the first season with Geena Davis better than the second season with the kids in the foster home. The first one was more straightforward with the story and background; I think they were going for more shock value in the 2nd series, with the reveal of the little girl with the pillow case mask and the possession of the foster dad -multiple plot attempts, too much for one season, they could have made one of the stories into a season 3.
In both seasons they were able to get the feel of a horror movie in every episode of the show and most of these horror TV shows fail spectacularly at that.