The OFFICIAL 2022 College Football RANDOM THOUGHTS thread

Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
73,878
Reputation
13,232
Daps
260,183
Reppin
206 & 734
can't coach a lick but man he can recruit
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
 

Freddie.Cane

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Joined
Jan 31, 2015
Messages
16,730
Reputation
19,085
Daps
87,633
Reppin
305 Canes, Dolphins, and Heat
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
Elite offensive coach
 

Freddie.Cane

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Joined
Jan 31, 2015
Messages
16,730
Reputation
19,085
Daps
87,633
Reppin
305 Canes, Dolphins, and Heat
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense
I’ll take this btw :hubie: you can pop on one offensive player as a homerun threat, or coach up a great OL….your defense will carry you far
I aint see the elite defense coach option cause if so I would of chose that
 

904Lurker

R.I.P Young Dolph
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
4,117
Reputation
994
Daps
14,249
Reppin
Jacksonville,Fl
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)Zook
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)Mullen
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense Mcilwaine
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense  Muschamp
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often No comment
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
I've had them all and I'm choosing elite defensive coordinator
 

DropTopDoc

Smokin my Opps like Patrick Mahomes pops
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
40,324
Reputation
6,324
Daps
81,267
Reppin
South Side Chicago to Nola
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
I’ll take the recruiter, the off/def guy will eventually get figured out, and you have to worry will he try to adapt or be stubborn ( see les, Jimbo, Hugh, leach) but with the recruiter, you just have to hope they hit on coordinators, and you cycle them every 4 or so years ( due to poaching/promoting) with the right talent you can do some things with the right coaching

Mario’s biggest issue is not letting his coordinators coordinate, and being too conservative( ironically it’s a political joke there too, a conservative Cuban in Miami go figure)
 
Top