The OFFICIAL 2022 College Football RANDOM THOUGHTS thread

Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
66,474
Reputation
10,866
Daps
231,385
Reppin
206 & 734
can't coach a lick but man he can recruit
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
 

Freddie.Cane

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Joined
Jan 31, 2015
Messages
16,730
Reputation
19,035
Daps
87,619
Reppin
305 Canes, Dolphins, and Heat
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
Elite offensive coach
 

Freddie.Cane

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Joined
Jan 31, 2015
Messages
16,730
Reputation
19,035
Daps
87,619
Reppin
305 Canes, Dolphins, and Heat
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense
I’ll take this btw :hubie: you can pop on one offensive player as a homerun threat, or coach up a great OL….your defense will carry you far
I aint see the elite defense coach option cause if so I would of chose that
 

904Lurker

R.I.P Young Dolph
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
4,040
Reputation
895
Daps
13,871
Reppin
Jacksonville,Fl
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)Zook
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)Mullen
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense Mcilwaine
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense  Muschamp
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often No comment
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
I've had them all and I'm choosing elite defensive coordinator
 

DropTopDoc

20/20 Vision With my Buffs On
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
36,750
Reputation
5,634
Daps
75,902
Reppin
South Side Chicago to Nola
That brings me to a group question.

What would yall like the most…a coach that:

  • Can recruit but can’t coach (both sides of the ball)
  • Can coach but can’t recruit (both sides of the ball)
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on offense but can’t coach or recruit on defense
  • Is an elite coach and recruiter on defense but cant coach or recruit on offense
  • Is “solid” on all sides of the ball, coaching and recruiting, but is awful at clock management and plays down to competition often
I have examples of each :mjgrin:
I’ll take the recruiter, the off/def guy will eventually get figured out, and you have to worry will he try to adapt or be stubborn ( see les, Jimbo, Hugh, leach) but with the recruiter, you just have to hope they hit on coordinators, and you cycle them every 4 or so years ( due to poaching/promoting) with the right talent you can do some things with the right coaching

Mario’s biggest issue is not letting his coordinators coordinate, and being too conservative( ironically it’s a political joke there too, a conservative Cuban in Miami go figure)
 
Top