"The Newsroom" debuts tonight on HBO...Official thread

daemonova

hit it, & I didn't go Erykah Badu crazy, #yallmad
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
44,737
Reputation
3,661
Daps
73,591
Great show yada yada.........

Lets get one thing clear, America is the Greatest Country That has Ever Existed or Ever Will Exist, and If You Don't Like Me Saying That, Kill Yourself
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
27,792
Reputation
4,712
Daps
103,465
Far too pretentious for me.

I'll sick with it, but I don't like the vibe I got from the first episode.
 

NelsonSwagdela

All Star
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
1,515
Reputation
352
Daps
4,372
Great show yada yada.........

Lets get one thing clear, America is the Greatest Country That has Ever Existed or Ever Will Exist, and If You Don't Like Me Saying That, Kill Yourself

Ignorance. My pops is in the navy and I have been to a lot of countries and this just isn't true it doesn't make you a bad american to admit there is so much wrong with it. Being a black man in Canada> being a black man almost anywhere in America.
 

obarth

R.I.P Char
Poster of the Year
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
16,844
Reputation
9,166
Daps
83,793
Reppin
Pawgs with dragons
- Hated all of the speeches. Thought it was funny when McAvoy said that MacKenzie's speech did nothing for him, because I felt the exact same way. Too preachy and idealistic. Sorkin has no grip of reality.
So you thought it was funny when a character said another character's over dramatic and idealistic speech did nothing for him yet you want to indict Sorkin for the scene anyway? So the fact Sorkin has his own character point out the silliness of the speech either went over your head or wasn't enough for you to find fault in the scene.
Found this funny.

Sorkinisms
The negative reviews I've seen of the show have one thing in common. They all center on who did the show as opposed to the faults of the show itse;f. Which tells me that some people are just tired of dude and his accolades and would rather go aganst the grain regardless of the shows merits.
Far too pretentious for me.
How?
 

daemonova

hit it, & I didn't go Erykah Badu crazy, #yallmad
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
44,737
Reputation
3,661
Daps
73,591
Ignorance. My pops is in the navy and I have been to a lot of countries and this just isn't true it doesn't make you a bad american to admit there is so much wrong with it. Being a black man in Canada> being a black man almost anywhere in America.

then move to canada breh
 

phillycavsfan

WAHOOWA
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
22,802
Reputation
1,672
Daps
45,317
Reppin
Philadelphia
So you thought it was funny when a character said another character's over dramatic and idealistic speech did nothing for him yet you want to indict Sorkin for the scene anyway? So the fact Sorkin has his own character point out the silliness of the speech either went over your head or wasn't enough for you to find fault in the scene.

Because if Sorkin really thought it was overdramatic and idealistic he wouldn't have wasted our time showing the speech. Obviously he agrees with Mortimer, and he's said as much in interviews. It was a whole lot of should-be's and maybe's with no sense of reality. It'd be like ranting about football being the best game ever if no one ever got injured.

The negative reviews I've seen of the show have one thing in common. They all center on who did the show as opposed to the faults of the show itse;f. Which tells me that some people are just tired of dude and his accolades and would rather go aganst the grain regardless of the shows merits.

You're only reading what you want to see. I think critics have panned it - and I can't fully agree because I've only seen the first episode - because it tries to make the point that cable news outlets should be more like this newsroom, despite the fact that the journalists on the show are breaking old news stories in a matter of minutes other reporters took hours, days, and sometimes weeks to break. It's like saying coaching football should really be easy, except you know what plays the other team was going to run on every play.

Maybe they're wrong and that new producer doesn't have relatives, college roommates, and acquaintances from kindergarten involved in every major news story.
 
Top