The Marshall Mathers LP was 1 of the most popular albums in the 2000s, is it a top 25 Hip Hop album?

[ORDER_66]

The Album was Meh to me...

 

[Figaro]

This is just a Slim Shady LP with better production arguably.

It did have significant impact but content hardly differ from the previous album and it’s made the album age badly.

It’s an album that strikes you greatly when you first hear it as a teenager but quality simmers down the older you get.

Has a few classic songs on there (Stan & The Way I Am)

But it’s not a classic album to me let alone top 25

 

[Newportbox]

Wasn't fukking with it from the gate

 

[Piffery]

I hate Eminem, actually think this album is great though, and play it occasionally, I also believe it aged well besides a few of the pop culture lines.
Only Eminem album I actually beleive is good, I hate the rest of his discography.
Not top 25 though.

 

[bordeaux]

sslp+tes+relapse>

 

[ThirdAct]

It's dope, but not 25. Too much filler. Slim Shady LP is better IMO, his best overall album, although that's not top 25 either.

 

[Rell84shots]

I like "Amityville" but that's it, Em's music would've aged better if he made more songs like "Rock Bottom".

 

[JQ Legend]

Easily

 

[nose hair]

Not even a top 250 hip hop album. Beat it cac

I'm Black
And I was using this album as an example of how something can be so big and popular and hyped up and not be classic at all when the dust settles.
Just goes to show u that a lot of albums can be some of the most popular albums of their time but then once time passes, it don't hold up.

 

[Soymuscle Mike]

Not close for me, but I wouldn't hate on anyone who has it in theirs (this or SSLP)

 

[Juggalo Fred]

no, Slim Anus LP was far better too

 

[Billy Ocean]

Hell no.

 

[Black_Panther_JS]

It might not be Top 25 of the 2000s, no hate but album wise Eminem is not the person you’d want to be listening to

 

[Black_Panther_JS]

The only reason this albums gets put on lists is cause it’s by Eminem

 

[The Ruler 09]

No.