So it's the stat itself it seems?
Now, I believe Floyd is Top 5 DOA in defense as well, but statistics wise, he's not the best today....it's Guillermo Rigondeaux who allows a 16% connect rate on him for his career while Floyd allows an 18% connect rate for his career (as recent as 12/2013 via compubox http://compuboxonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/CompuBoxLeaders_Dec2014.pdf).
Defense takes into account not allowing your opponent to hit you, but also your competition (which Floyd has faced great comp) and the punches you can sustain (considering Floyd has never been officially knocked down in his career, I would give him the edge over mostly everyone because his chin is strong and a body shot hasnt taken him down either)
I am on this though, because it's a slippery slope. Going by opponents connection pct to use as a basis for calling someone the greatest, you'd also have to go by total connect pct landed on opponents...which means the top 9 best offensive boxers today are in order Floyd, JCC Jr, Alvarez, Ward, LSC, Khan, Agbeko, Lara, and Lamont Peterson and the most COMPLETE boxers today (+/- on punches landed for them vs landed on them) are Floyd, LSC, Lara, Ward, Canelo, Rigo, Wlad, and Moreno. I dont think anyone would stand behind that statement, but it cant be 1 way without the other
Numbers don't tell the whole story, but you when got the numbers to go with the intangible things like adjustments, longevity, it says a lot
regardless of compettion, the best fighters floyd face connect percentage are around worst fighters he faced, that type of consistency cannot be denied
I think it was vs. hernandez Floyd 64 percent of his punches majority power shots and herndanez only landed 18 percent of his entire punch total, that shyt is retarded I don't care who it is your fighting, that is crazy
also when you watch tape you just see a different level of command, floyd really know what he doing
why you think everybody who try to shoulder roll can't do it, Oscar tried against Vargas and was getting tagged along the ropes, broner we all seen what happened, they don't think fast enough to use effectively and they don't know how to throw punches off roll