The Coli Official Boxing Controversial Decision Thread

[SuikodenII]

Foreman-Schulz................wait for it.................instant karma.....................wait for it.............

Foreman-Briggs

 

[patscorpio]

Holyfield-Lewis 1

ill never forget my dad's reaction...like myself he was a big holyfield fan and we were all ..when they announced that draw..my dad jumped up like yes!!! and ran up and down the hallway

 

[SuikodenII]

Toney-Tiberi..............waaaaaaaaaaait for it.......................instant karma charging up............waaaaaaaaaaaaait fooooooooooooor iiiiiiiiiiiit.................



Toney-Peter 1

 

[SuikodenII]

Leonard-Hearns II



When Ray said to Tommy on ESPN that he (Tommy) won that fight, my respect for Sugar grew 3 times larger that day..............

 

[patscorpio]

james toney is my nikka...but this one was egregious..he lost this shyt....weight drained and damn near out on his feet at the final bell...i felt for tiberi..

 

[seemorecizzy]

Oscar De La Hoya is one of boxing most "gifted" fighters. I am not talking about talent. I am talking about decisions in his fights.

I believe he lost without question against Sweet Pea.

He never hurt him or landed anything significant. Whitaker was just not given enough credit for his defense in that fight. He really made Oscar look stupid. Pea's jab kept Oscar's timing off all night. Oscar looked like an amateur. Whitaker also was credited with a KD. The judges were not having it though. Nothing at that time was gonna derail the DLH money train.

Oscar also got a gift against Sturm. I believe Oscar beat Tito, but was served poetic justice. I dont know if I would call that a robbery and DLH looked really bytchmade complaining about the decision afterwards. I thought he lost to Quartey...I wouldnt say it was controversial though.

Oscar is the king of this
At that one judge giving him the w against floyd

 

[patscorpio]

carlos molina vs jcc jr 1 and 2 - jr lost both of these shyts clearly..first of the gifts that bytch ass nikka got


matter of fact jr vs matt vanda in the first fight - another gift

 

[patscorpio]

leonard dorin vs paul spadafora...i liked dorin alot and couldn't stand spaddy for anything...dorin beat that ass..this was no gotdamned draw

 

[ChocolateGiddyUp]

carlos molina vs jcc jr 1 and 2 - jr lost both of these shyts clearly..first of the gifts that bytch ass nikka got


matter of fact jr vs matt vanda in the first fight - another gift

 

[patscorpio]

this fight alone is the reason i never want to see sven ottke in the HOF...fukk him

 

[surv2syn]

carlos molina vs jcc jr 1 and 2 - jr lost both of these shyts clearly..first of the gifts that bytch ass nikka got


matter of fact jr vs matt vanda in the first fight - another gift

now see, this was when I wasnt watching Jr. u mean to tell me he had controversial wins over these guys? Matt the Predator Vanda??? say it aint so.

 

[surv2syn]

Whitaker vs Chavez draw. pure bull manure.

also...this fight was rigged

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Would the first Roy Jones-Montell Griffin fight be considered a controversial decision?

 

[surv2syn]

I picked Bradley to beat Manny. I REALLY wanted to but didnt bet money because I thought Bradley would get robbed despite doing enough to win the fight. When the fight was over, I was like glad I didnt bet because Bradley lost that fight. My pockets wouldve been light.

*hears scorecards*

 

[patscorpio]

Would the first Roy Jones-Montell Griffin fight be considered a controversial decision?

nah the DQ was justified..roy clearly hit dude when he was down