Survival of the Fittest: Official 2014 New York Giants Season Thread

[AJtheOne]

Question - assuming that Cruz will not nearly be at 100% next year, and after the subpar this guy has had in Indy...if Nicks were to want to come back after not being offered much elsewhere & comes back in shape, pleads his case to being committed the whole nine, would you re-sign him??

breh, Nicks is he's a shell of his former self

I wouldn't be surprised to see the Giants give him a shot tho

 

[Adebisi_Said]

Question - assuming that Cruz will not nearly be at 100% next year, and after the subpar this guy has had in Indy...if Nicks were to want to come back after not being offered much elsewhere & comes back in shape, pleads his case to being committed the whole nine, would you re-sign him??

I'd rather see how Ruben Randle develops.

 

[Rev]

I'd rather see how Ruben Randle develops.

No doubt about it...not saying Randle would take a backseat at all. I'm saying having Nicks for depth and all considering that Cruz isn't a sure thing IMO. But whatever, Reese rarely ever looks back...especially with WRs.

 

[HarlemUSA]

Question - assuming that Cruz will not nearly be at 100% next year, and after the subpar this guy has had in Indy...if Nicks were to want to come back after not being offered much elsewhere & comes back in shape, pleads his case to being committed the whole nine, would you re-sign him??

Why not? We did it with Mario Manningham. You need camp bodies.

 

[HarlemUSA]

@ Will Hill tho.




















#sour

 

[MAGNETO.]

ALL THE WAY IN.

 

[MAGNETO.]

Would love to see us develop some red zone options and packages to utilise Washington. I know the kids raw but he'd be a threat there. In regards to Nicks I don't know. Would have to see him in camp and OTA's. Maybe give him the pre-season. And on another note seeing Will Hill prosper was bitter-sweet. He was a steal for the Ravens. Given our lack of depth in that position it hurts even more. Smh.

 

[Tobias]

not optimistic about what we're gonna get from Cruz.

that injury is no joke. he is never gonna be the same player as he once was which is really sad. him and odb together woulda been the best 1-2 in the league

 

[DirtyD]

Offseason Thread: http://www.thecoli.com/threads/we-d...york-football-giants-offseason-thread.281232/

 

[godkiller]

Why are Giants' fans still talking about wide receivers? Eli has enough help on that side of the ball.

 

[Tobias]

Why are Giants' fans still talking about wide receivers? Eli has enough help on that side of the ball.

yes and no

odb is obviously amazing. but we don't know how Cruz is gonna come back nor do we know if randle can consistently play like he did at the end of the year

 

[godkiller]

yes and no

odb is obviously amazing. but we don't know how Cruz is gonna come back nor do we know if randle can consistently play like he did at the end of the year

ODB is a Pro Bowler. Cruz is a former Pro Bowler. Randle is better than average. The excuses for Eli's ineptitude have to end.

 

[Derek Lee]

ODB is a Pro Bowler. Cruz is a former Pro Bowler. Randle is better than average. The excuses for Eli's ineptitude have to end.

30 touchdowns and 14 ints, 4,410 passing yards, career high in completion % and second highest qb rating despite playing with a terrible o-line are not cases for ineptitude breh.

 

[Tobias]

ODB is a Pro Bowler. Cruz is a former Pro Bowler. Randle is better than average. The excuses for Eli's ineptitude have to end.

never said anything about giving eli an excuse

using Cruz's past history as an argument is dumb. the injury he suffered is bad and their is precedent for never being the same after it

randle came on strong at the end of the year but he's inconsistent and needs to put together a full year before i am confident in him

we will bring in a wr or 2 without a doubt

 

[HarlemUSA]

he's an Atl fan talking about Eli has enough weapons