Piff Perkins
Veteran
Did yall even watch the video? They both addressed that. And they were right. 100%. Matter fact. I feel like hip hop is too busy sampling other hip hop. Hip hop artists in the past had an appreciation for the music prior to hip hop like soul music, funk, rnb etc etc. So they were putting a new spin on the samples that wasn't there before. Thats damn near ENTIRELY missing today. Cats like Dre would go and actually get the funk artists and have them replay and interpolate the samples as well. There was musicianship and appreciation. Cats like Havoc would flip a sample so crazy the shyt wouldn't even be discovered until like 20 years later. Thats one thing someone like Kendrick does and it's so rare that it's extremely noticeable which is why he gets so much praise for doing so. It's not many artists willing to do what he's doing. Kanye used to. But he's nuts. Tyler does. Which is why he stands out as well.
On one hand I agree with you, on another I don't. Looking back at early 90s hip hop, if we rewind the clock from 1992 by 20 years, that puts you in 1972. If we do the same from 2024, you get 2004. I don't think it's crazy that producers today are mining the early 2000s anymore than 90s producers mining the 1970s. Go ask your parents what they think about Mo Money Mo Problems and most of them gonna say that shyt is lazy as fukk. It's a straight up loop of the original record. And frankly while Dre did get musicians to replay samples at times and is a great producer....a lot of his most iconic beats are straight loops of 1970s funk.
The part I agree with you on is that the 2000s sample records not only sample the beat, the rapper is basically re-doing the melody of the original song plus taking the hook in many cases. Mo Money Mo Murder has a basic sample loop like I said but Mase comes up with his own melody/flow. He's not jacking Diana Ross' melody and integrating it into a rap performance, he's doing his own thing based on the pocket of the record. Compare that to the queen of this lazy ass shyt....