SBE X ODB:Thats Tha Gang Biitch --The Official 2018 New York Giants OffSeason Thread

[Rev]

whose mans is this (McAdoo)?? who were the other choices, and why wasn't Jerry allowed to hire them?????

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

who's mans is this (McAdoo)?? who were the other choices, and why wasn't Jerry allowed to hire them?????

He was a lame duck after Coughlin got fired

Ironically he sabotaged the roster Coughlins last year to get his own coach in which never happened

 

[Exit9NJturnpike]

Realistically we should've done this 2 years ago after Coughlin the 11-5 season was an anomaly. This team has been awful for awhile. Time to get rid of some players too, Jenkins and Apple should get traded. Please bring in a GM that knows how to manipulate the draft and stockpile picks.

I still want to see Davis-Webb play, finding the right GM will be huge. The new GM will pick the next coach and draft our next franchise QB. Can't fukk this up, especially with having to face Dak and Wentz the next 10 yrs.

 

[puggle]

It's too bad they both got fired during the holidays but Mcadoo's tough guy act was tiring. You can give short, non informative answers if you're Belichick, not when you're 2-10 and lost the control of the team.

 

[woof]

To be fair, McAdoo was hired off his work as OC. It made a lot of sense, given how they were performing despite the talent deficiencies... but then as soon as the Coughlin influence on his offense was subtracted,

 

[AJtheOne]

 

[JerseyBoy23]

I'm happy Reese is gone as a Giants fan. As a black man, I hope that Reese gets another job and doesn't get blackballed by the league.

 

[ImGucci]

You dont fukk with a made man and live fvk boys


Eli told the wolves to handle it.

 

[PIFF101]

Reese for not getting OL which we desperately needed amongst other things and McAdoo well you already know

 

[woof]

I'm happy Reese is gone as a Giants fan. As a black man, I hope that Reese gets another job and doesn't get blackballed by the league.

Before he was GM, he was the GOAT Director Player Personnel. His work there helped set the foundation for both titles.

Maybe not another GM gig, but no way he shouldn't get another job of decent standing for a team.

 

[woof]

"But he did text me — typical Eli — he said, ‘Yessir. I met with John Mara,’ ” Archie Manning told The Post on Wednesday night. “And he said: ‘It went well.’"

 

[Prime Time J]

Whole thing is a fukking mess. Was it really worth benching Eli?

 

[JMurder]

Reese gone

McAdoo... I was riding for you in spite of all the dumb shyt but you had to go after benching Eli and talking shyt about him in season.

They've been sending Reese out to scout players -- they're not firing him.

I respect you as a poster. Let me make this argument here: Reese drafted Engram (hit), Flowers (hit), OBJ (superstar hit), etc, no? If he hits on Geno (and the numbers says he has), he is a top 5 scouting GM. Most GMs don't even hit on their 1st rounders which is the most important round. Reese hits on his 1st rounders almost every year.

This nikka called Flowers a hit

Flowers has been good for most of the season. He's a hit. He doesnt have to play well every game for be good LT. Bosa abused Tyron Smith in Dallas' last game, that doesn't make Tyron Smith a bad LT.

Eli Apple is only acting the way he is because he was shouldering blame from fans for losing games. He left his first Giants' game in a bad loss. The defense played well and the offense sputtered, yet people were picking on him. The same thing affected Janoris and he came back. Apple will do the same.

If McAdoo and Reese are wrong, Geno or Webb won't win games, and both should be fired. However if Geno or Webb win games, McAdoo and Reese are right and should be kept.

 

[krazykid18]

Whole thing is a fukking mess. Was it really worth benching Eli?

YEs it is, lets see if we have a good qb or a stopgap qb in Webb or Geno might as well not draft a qb this yr and trade it for assets and build a better team like yo ELi is not the same dude his deep ball is gone and his accuracy which has been streaky, got worst.

Like i can't forgive him for ending Odell's season

 

[StretfordRed]

I'm shocked about Reese, especially in season.

Gives credence to how Mara's puppet Dottino was going in about both he and McAdoo going into business for themselves in the Eli situation though. They fukked around and brought on the biggest PR disaster possible, had even children's cancer charities dragging the org, and now are paying for it.

This isn’t fully true

Mara suggested to Reece that they should give the other QBs a look.

But I think they handled it wrong in dropping him. Let the other QBs come in when the game is deadly