2 Up 2 Down
Veteran
I'll be reading it before my second viewing
And then novelization before my third viewing
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story [Official Thread]
- Thread starter CHL
- Start date
And then novelization before my third viewing
Grand Conde
Superstar
When we getting reviews brehs? Its out the 14th where I am.
Grand Conde
Superstar
What's the 'Catalyst'?
2 Up 2 Down
Veteran
JerseyBoy23
Veteran
Strong words coming from the Jedi Council boys.
If feel like they said the same for TFA
Kill Dat Noize
Banned
John Campea called MOS a masterpiece.
MASTERPIECE.
Safe to say you have to take his reaction with a grain of salt.
MASTERPIECE.
Safe to say you have to take his reaction with a grain of salt.
Jmare007
pico pal q lee
I'm actually excited by what Harloff said. No overraction but high praise. And he has no issue calling a hyped movie out when it's just "meh".
HipHopStan
Top 113 Poster
It's been awhile since I've paid attention to these dudes. I almost forgot that they existed.
Hope all is well over there at Collider.
HipHopStan
Top 113 Poster
BTW - I got my tickets for Thursday at 7:00 in IMAX 3D.
Merry Christmas to me.
Merry Christmas to me.
Dr. Narcisse
Veteran
Harloff was the only one that didn't overreact to TFA.
He gave it a 4.2 out of 5 instead of 5 stars like the rest of them.
Now being the Star Wars fanboy that he is..... he ended up saying it was the 2nd best film of the year after multiple re-watches.
Last edited:
HipHopStan
Top 113 Poster
Harloff was the only one that didn't overreact to TFA.
He gave it a 4.2 out of 5 instead of 5 stars like the rest of them.
Now being the Star Wars fanboy that he is..... he ended up saying it was the 2nd best film of the year after multiple re-watches.
Looking back, I think a lot of reviewers gave TFA a #1 or #2 spot on their year end list (Jahns and Stuckman did as well, I think). Much later on, I think Jahns called it 'a very flawed film' though. So you gave a very flawed film a top 3 spot of the year?
Roman Brady
Nobody Lives Forever
They don't sound overly enthused I mean look at him in the pic it's like a hostage picture. I heard Disney wines and dines the press at these early screeners so most of these film critics are hard pressed to say anything negative
Roman Brady
Nobody Lives Forever
Princess Leia stayed in her lane though this Kathleen Kennedy person is putting princesses front and centre all over this thing. We are going to look back on these new joints and say they were sissified
Kill Dat Noize
Banned
In the Star Wars universe it should actually be the opposite of what we do here... women should not be allowed to lay their hands on a man under any circumstances. They're clearly too physically strong and superior. It isn't even fair.
