This narrative is such bullshyt im not gonna go into it because i already have before but arguably two of the best perimeter defenders in the league are 6'4 and 6'3 teams hid zone defenses all the time and you could hand check nikkas back then.
A 6'3" person "can" be a good defender. Like I pointed out, Joe Dumars and Gary Payton were two of the guys who defended MJ most effectively.
But as a general rule, bigger is better. Kawhi Leonard and Jimmy Butler and Andre Iguodala defend Lebron a lot better than Avery Bradley and Tony Allen and Patrick Beverley do. If you have to defend a great scorer who is 6'6", 220lbs, and you have two potential defenders of equal talent, you sure as hell are going to prefer to put 6'6", 220lb JR Smith in front of him rather than 6'4", 180lb Jeff Hornacek.
If you have EVER played basketball, and yet want to claim that height and weight and athleticism don't play a factor in ability to D someone up, I'm going to have to call you a liar. And the era where Jeff Hornacek and Craig Ehlo and Dan Majerle and Byron Scott and John Starks were Jordan's primary defender in huge playoff series did not have the height or the size or the athleticism to hang with Jordan.
Not that it isn't possible that he'd still be the GOAT if he played right now. But on a night-to-night basis, he'd have to do it against tougher defenders.
And YES, you could hand-check in that era. Now, who is that going to favor, some 180lb White guy or the 6'6", 220lb guard who happens to be the greatest two-way player in the league?
Last edited: