Questlove defends Vol 1, Jay-Z responds

Mr. Negative

Can't change overnight like Ebenezer
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
28,573
Reputation
7,976
Daps
80,400
Reppin
A Mississippi Cotton Field
Vol 2 don't have the highs of Vol. 1 but is just a smoother overall listen. Worst track is Paper Chase but that's not even close to as awful as Vol 1s lows. My breakdown would be this

Vol. 1:

Intro - 10
City Is Mine - 6.5
I Know What Girls Like - 1
Imaginary Player - 9.5
Streets Is Watching - 10
Friend or Foe 98 - 8.5
Lucky Me - 6
Sunshine - 7
Who You Wit - 8.5
Face Off - 5.5
Real nikkaz - 7
Rap Game/Crack Game - 8.5
Where I'm From -10
You Must Love Me - 9

Vol 2:
Intro - 9
Hard Knock Life - 8
If I Should Die - 7
Ride or Die - 9
nikka What nikka Who - 9
Money Cash Hoes - 7.5
A Week Ago - 10
Coming of Age - 8.5
Can I Get A - 9
Paper Chase - 6
Reservoir Dogs - 8.5
It's Like That - 9.5

More cohesive, better sequenced, and consistent


I wholeheartedly agree with this.

Vol 1 will have you going from :gladbron: to :what: to :gladbron: to :what: when you listening
 

Alexander Wiggin

All Star
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
3,402
Reputation
1,347
Daps
10,386
Reppin
Paris Saint-Germain
:russ: it used to feel like I was the only nikka on the face of the earth that liked "Sunshine"

I know what Girls like, though? It was trash then and it's trash now. :francis:

Same here. I actually like sunshine. It's the video that gave the song a bad rep. But I know what girls like is horrendous, the city is mine awful. I don't understand why Nas got a bad rep for his beat sélection and jay somehow don't get called out with beats like theses
 

Clapsteel O'Neal

put a red dot on your head like a hindu
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
16,536
Reputation
2,884
Daps
42,249
Reppin
NULL
Vol.1 is one or two missteps from being classic but "I know what girls like" is hot garbage

I still can't figure out who that song was even for? bytches didn't like it, heads didn't like it
most jay stans don't fukk with it.....who was suppose to rock with that shyt? song shouldn't even exist
the beat isn't bad nor is the rapping it just makes no sense as a song if quest thinks its was something more
to that shyt he needs to break it down cause I really don't see it

After reading this thread
nikkas who don't like 'Lucky Me" got horrible taste that song is a work of art and the beat is :ohlawd:

"Lucky Me" is also the only song Jay said he made as "SC"
his Jay-Z persona is nowhere to be found on the track its one of a kind and fukking classic

oh and anybody who thinks vol.3 is more lyrical than vol.1 is smoking crack that opinion is retarded
Jay even admitted he phoned that album in

its a good seven to ten songs on vol.1 thats the best shyt Jay-Z ever put out :wow:

replace sunshine and I know what girls like with these two and its classic!





:laff::laff::laff::laff::laff: at this pretentious sh't
 
  • Dap
Reactions: ADP

Heavy_Handz

Superstar
Joined
Apr 5, 2017
Messages
10,583
Reputation
2,074
Daps
28,955
Reppin
Dallas, TX
You’re making two different arguments now. RD was not a successful album in real time, commercially. Jay has admitted this himself on records. So the idea that his second album was heavily anticipated or that people thought he was next up after Biggie is false. Jay clearly thought he was next up, which is why half the album sounds like a Bad Boy imitation. But I’m not buying that he was seen as “that guy” yet.

Album came out and did ok, eventually going plat with no hit records. Jay didn’t become JAY until Hard Knock Life.
His original title for Vol. 1 was “Heir to the Throne” and was actually titled as that in The Source as anticipated albums before he changed it to Vol. 1 because he didn’t want anybody to think he was being disrespectful after Biggie passed. His album absolutely was highly anticipated by real heads. I never said he was a platinum selling artist out the gate.
 

mitter

All Star
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
3,482
Reputation
-58
Daps
9,458
Reppin
NULL
I think In My Lifetime Vol. 1 is Jay-Z's second best album

People go on and on about the failed crossover attempts, but that was like 2-3 songs (and I actually liked "Sunshine" a lot). The rest of it was raw.
 

987654321

Superstar
Joined
Jun 15, 2018
Messages
7,528
Reputation
3,767
Daps
27,451
Same here. I actually like sunshine. It's the video that gave the song a bad rep. But I know what girls like is horrendous, the city is mine awful. I don't understand why Nas got a bad rep for his beat sélection and jay somehow don't get called out with beats like theses

:mjcry:
I was with y’all until I got to the “city is mine” hate. It was a good way to smoothly open the door to the rest of the album. I know what girls like was irredeemable though lol.
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,202
Reputation
3,789
Daps
47,630
Reppin
NULL
I don't understand why Nas got a bad rep for his beat sélection and jay somehow don't get called out with beats like theses

Breh, it should be obvious at this point. It was never about Nas's beat selection. That was just a way for people who wanted Nas to work with their favorite producer to cover for saying "this beat sucks because (insert favorite producer) didn't make it". All that hate came during the era of Salaam producing for Nas and then 9th made God's Stepson and it opened the flood gates of people (even so called Nas fans) to argue that Nas had weak beat selection.
 

Tommy Gibbs

Superstar
Joined
Oct 22, 2017
Messages
5,184
Reputation
978
Daps
13,571
I think In My Lifetime Vol. 1 is Jay-Z's second best album

People go on and on about the failed crossover attempts, but that was like 2-3 songs (and I actually liked "Sunshine" a lot). The rest of it was raw.
what is up with you guys claiming Vol 1 is better than Blueprint.. You cannot be serious!!! Blueprint is a damn near flawless album. Even Hola Hovita is better than those shytty wannabe bad boy songs yall praising from Vol 1.
 

FunkDoc1112

Heavily Armed
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
19,330
Reputation
5,753
Daps
100,823
Reppin
The 718
Breh, it should be obvious at this point. It was never about Nas's beat selection. That was just a way for people who wanted Nas to work with their favorite producer to cover for saying "this beat sucks because (insert favorite producer) didn't make it". All that hate came during the era of Salaam producing for Nas and then 9th made God's Stepson and it opened the flood gates of people (even so called Nas fans) to argue that Nas had weak beat selection.
I mean maybe, but Nas was definitely rapping over weaker production on HHID and Untitled (Id say Streets Disciple but its a double album so im not sure if the weak beats are bad selection or just the filler all double albums end up suffering from). It may have started under false pretense but he sure as hell went on to earn it.
 
Last edited:
Top