Put Some Hornacek On Our Game: 2016 New York Knicks Offseason Thread

[GetInTheTruck]

Some of the criticisms of melo are valid but the exaggerated hatred for him is retarded. The knicks are a better team with him on the floor period.

 

[The War Report]

Some of the criticisms of melo are valid but the exaggerated hatred for him is retarded. The knicks are a better team with him on the floor period.

Marginally. Some of y'all need to wake the fukk up. :sassigh:

 

[OsO]

You think Fisher has a rotation look for Amundson to get all the minutes next week.

so who do we trade seraphin or KOQ cause there is no reason to keep both

Trade Seraphin. OQuinn gives you points, rebs, assists and solid defense. Seraphin doesn't have that many dimensions.

@Mr. Jack Napier

He could average 45ppg for the rest of the season and I'd still say they should trade him before it's too late.

You would trade someone averaging 45ppg You don't sound objective

Too late for what? Some mid first round picks and role players who can barely hang on in the league like Denver did? You don't trade box office guys for garbage.

Exactly ... ain't nobody tryna trade Melo for a bunch of bums.

Look at the Grizzlies as an example of a team that didn't know when to move on.

The Grizzlies window is far from closed... and we're only 25 games into this season.

Some of the criticisms of melo are valid but the exaggerated hatred for him is retarded. The knicks are a better team with him on the floor period.

Marginally. Some of y'all need to wake the fukk up. :sassigh:

The disrespect

 

[GetInTheTruck]

Marginally. Some of y'all need to wake the fukk up. :sassigh:

It's not marginally at all. I'm not opposed to trading melo for the right deal but some knick fans acting like he's eddy curry or some shyt.

 

[Wargames]

 

[seemorecizzy]

nothing positive can come from trading melo right now
we'll simply go back to the 2002-2009 era of losing where we have no stars
why some ppl are so eager to go back there, i'll never know
phil gotta get some free agents over here
so far every move he has made minus affalo hasnt worked out

 

[JMurder]

nothing positive can come from trading melo right now
we'll simply go back to the 2002-2009 era of losing where we have no stars
why some ppl are so eager to go back there, i'll never know
phil gotta get some free agents over here
so far every move he has made minus afflalo hasnt worked out

You don't think the inconsistent minutes and rotations might have something to do with that?

 

[pimpineasy]

I could outline all the mid to late first rounders in the league contributing, but I know that wont matter


It's funny you mention Denver, since they actually have a better record since the Melo trade than the Knicks


Too late, as in before you can't get any kind of value for him, last year it was Jimmy Butler & Niko for him, this year it's "Hey, maybe we can get some mid first rounders?". You get value for him while he still has some and accept the reality of the situation which is the Knicks are not going to win a title with Melo, so why exactly hold onto him like he's the difference between winning and losing a ring?

Look at the Grizzlies as an example of a team that didn't know when to move on.

I'll go one step further ....... we will never get to the ecf with melo as our central player and if that is true why have him on the team when we pay hi m so much

 

[seemorecizzy]

You don't think the inconsistent minutes and rotations might have something to do with that?

The thing is,
He also hired the coach

 

[JMurder]

I'll go one step further ....... we will never get to the ecf with melo as our central player and if that is true why have him on the team when we pay hi m so much

by the time his contract is up, it'll be considered a bargain

 

[GunRanger]

Koq and derrick should be rotation guys every night. How can guys be consistent when they dont get consistent miNutes?

 

[Liquid]

nothing positive can come from trading melo right now
we'll simply go back to the 2002-2009 era of losing where we have no stars
why some ppl are so eager to go back there, i'll never know
phil gotta get some free agents over here
so far every move he has made minus affalo hasnt worked out

We had no picks in many of those awful years and no promising prospect.

Carmelo is a net negative in the long run on this team and it's a shame that some of you guy's STILL don't see it.

 

[Mr. Jack Napier]

We had no picks in many of those awful years and no promising prospect.

Carmelo is a net negative in the long run on this team and it's a shame that some of you guy's STILL don't see it.

Enlighten the rest of us, please.

 

[Liquid]

Enlighten the rest of us, please.

You guys have several pages you can read by people using common sense, what more do you want?

 

[Mr. Jack Napier]

You guys have several pages you can read by people using common sense, what more do you want?

So no answer huh?