Proof that the "anti-identity politics" crowd means only white identity politics

the next guy

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
39,512
Reputation
1,553
Daps
37,690
Reppin
NULL
This is a college professor. Stop.
You misread me. I'm glad this was written because the narrative that only the white yokels were racist needs to die. White people from all backgrounds hold this opinion, and it's time the dems confronted that, even if it means they lose some money.
 

the next guy

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
39,512
Reputation
1,553
Daps
37,690
Reppin
NULL
I will never understand how Bernie, who if elected President would've at least attempted to redistribute more wealth then any other President since FDR to minorities, is pegged as the "for Whites" candidate.

I think it's because the center left is just a bunch of race-baiters tbh.
race baiters? :francis:

Negged. :camdup:
They aren't race baitiers anymore then the right. The problem is Bernie actually had the gall to say doublespeak on democracy while taking money from Wall Street was probably not a good thing to do.
 

Prince.Skeletor

Don’t Be Like He-Man
Bushed
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
28,924
Reputation
-7,199
Daps
56,267
Reppin
Bucktown
Guyssssssss
Are the right guilty of identity politics too.. Yes...
Does that mean that it always means white identity?
Come onnnn......

Both are guilty of it and NONE OF US should participate!!
 

GnauzBookOfRhymes

Superstar
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
12,507
Reputation
2,832
Daps
47,891
Reppin
NULL
Random thoughts.

One thing I always recommend is to look at the people who are really driving a particular movement/narrative. Are they look like the people who they claim to be defending?

Remember that it was the centrist/moderate "wing" of the Democratic Party that originally sought to extinguish the influence of those who practiced identity politics. They been playing that card for YEARS, and did so over and over against Obama.

Now they are using it as a weapon. The irony!

I'm not going to get into a back and forth about what role identity politics should play in the future of the Dem Party. People's personal experiences are so different it's more likely we end up talking past each other than anything else. But ideological purity is NEVER a good idea. Always ends up in failure at the polls. Now, going back to my first statement - when you see the people who are pushing this kind of purity, very often they are immune to the repercussions that come with losing. My ex girlfriend was in the middle of a PhD program and thus was very active at her university (where she also taught). She epitomized the social justice movement, and she taught me a lot about how and why they frame certain issues in particular ways. And it gave me a more nuanced understanding than people who reflexively oppose any idea proposed by a person/group branded as social justice warriors.

But the one thing I always mentioned to her, and which she begrudgingly agreed, was that although she was black and did not come from a privileged background by ANY means, she was NOW in a position whereby no matter what happened at the polls her position was secure. She had the right degrees from the right universities and the right network that ensured she would continue to thrive no matter what happened. That will cloud your judgment and unfortunately it's something I see on both sides of this argument.
 

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
52,342
Reputation
19,211
Daps
285,315
My problem with "identity politics" is that when taken to its extremes you get some real stupid shyt. Remember when Trump's cabinet was revealed and we got all those tweets/articles/etc about how there wasn't enough diversity? What worth is racial/gender diversity when there is no ideological diversity? Would you praise Trump if his cabinet was entirely made up of women who believe everything Sarah Palin believes? Your racial/gender identity does not guarantee you can provide a diverse perspective. We saw that in the election as a majority of white women voted for Trump despite him spending months attacking a white woman (Hillary) and being a sexist.
 
Top