Phil Simms Says Eli is not Elite?

[jking23258]

Simms: Eli isn't elite - Giants Blog - ESPN New York



this guy sounds like such a hater he was the one saying how Elite Eli was last season this guy is a hypocrite I think he's jeolous of Eli
I know Eli has had a few bad games in a row but he's still a great QB in my opinion.

 

[Futuristic Eskimo]

Its sad watching sports discussions become more and more reactionary

 

[Tony D'Amato]

Its a lot of qbs Id take over Eli tho. I still think Romo is more talented than him, and I hate Romo

Eli turns into Rain Man in the postseason tho

 

[jking23258]

Its sad watching sports discussions become more and more reactionary

yeah its crazy

 

[jking23258]

Its a lot of qbs Id take over Eli tho. I still think Romo is more talentef than him, and I hate Romo

I would take Eli all day over Romo

 

[PTBG]

Josh Freeman>Eli at this point in the season

 

[jking23258]

Josh Freeman>Eli at this point in the season

Cant argue that at the moment I think Eli will play better the next few games

 

[nyknick]

Everyone has a blog nowadays, so you gotta write something to get attention.

 

[THE MACHINE]

Is it possible that his elite status wasn't quite etched in stone and he has dropped just below the elite line? I guess I'm trying to ask, when does elite become permanent?

 

[DStyles]

Its a lot of qbs Id take over Eli tho. I still think Romo is more talented than him, and I hate Romo

Eli turns into Rain Man in the postseason tho

How many Games romo is gonna win you in the post season?

After all, he(Romo, seahawks) did eliminate the Cowboys from the playoffs in '06

 

[jking23258]

Is it possible that his elite status wasn't quite etched in stone and he has dropped just below the elite line? I guess I'm trying to ask, when does elite become permanent?

I feel like its never permanent in the NFL if you play bad for a few games people will say how bad you are and ignore how good you performed in the past

 

[DStyles]

Is it possible that his elite status wasn't quite etched in stone and he has dropped just below the elite line? I guess I'm trying to ask, when does elite become permanent?

Maybe if he wins a third one?

Once he gets that third one, Eli can go back to putting fukkboy numbers while letting the D carry the team to the post season and then he can come and

 

[PTBG]

Cant argue that at the moment I think Eli will play better the next few games

Yea I thought Freeman just had a hecka lucky season 2 years ago and was a bum, but now he has been killing shyt so far. I don't know what is up with Eli, its like all he is looking for is the big time plays and want to just throw it deep to Cruz all the time. Seems like he has been impatient the way he has been playing, but I'm sure he is gonna pick it up late into the season like he usually does.

 

[seemorecizzy]

Its a lot of qbs Id take over Eli tho. I still think Romo is more talented than him, and I hate Romo

Eli turns into Rain Man in the postseason tho

He is not more talented den eli
For da last time
Tony romo suckssssssssss

 

[jking23258]

How many Games romo is gonna win you in the post season?

After all, he did eliminate the Cowboys from the playoffs in '06

deff and it was 07