People who beat TLOU Part 2, what's your rating from playing it?

[Deuterion]

That's exactly what this game is
Everything is forced
The game is one big attempt to get you to like a new character AT THE DETRIMENT OF EVERYTHING ELSE
Who thought introducing a new character by making them kill off not only one of the main characters but the symbol of the game in the first two hours, then have you play as her for half the game was a good idea?
Not only that, you don't even kill her in the end
Ellie let's her go after she bites two of her fingers off and has a random flashback of Joel
Ellie kills hundreds of people for no reason
The story sucks there is no way around it
The game is upsetting in the sense that Neil had alternate story lines w/ Joel and Ellie and chose this one
The playable flashbacks w/ Joel were the best parts of the game in terms of the story having an emotional impact
I would have preferred another Joel and Ellie adventure w/ Joel dying in Part 3 or dying more reasonably and much later on (midway or at the end) in Part 2
They made Joel dumb as fukk in Part 2 and has a new personality in Part 2 that doesn't make sense
Dumbass Neil

That’s that disrespectful stuff that developers do, don’t kill off the people we like...fork the series or something if you want to get creative. Same shyt 343 did with Halo 5 with Agent Locke...it’s like...

“Who the fukk is this nikka and why am I not playing as Chief?”


Same shyt is Mass Effect when they killed off Shepherd...if you ain’t the walking dead stop acting like you can discard key characters without flack. Mario is like 35 and that nikka ain’t been killed off once and his games are as fresh as they ever have been.

 

[Cladyclad]

This shyt deserves more than a 10

those last 5 hours are the most I ever was tense in a game

surpasses the 1st on every metric

can’t even vote because I had no issues with this game. I never thought GOW would be surpassed to me. Not one moment did I get bored.

 

[CrimsonTider]

That’s that disrespectful stuff that developers do, don’t kill off the people we like...fork the series or something if you want to get creative. Same shyt 343 did with Halo 5 with Agent Locke...it’s like...

“Who the fukk is this nikka and why am I not playing as Chief?”


Same shyt is Mass Effect when they killed off Shepherd...if you ain’t the walking dead stop acting like you can discard key characters without flack. Mario is like 35 and that nikka ain’t been killed off once and his games are as fresh as they ever have been.

No those Mario games aren’t fresh as they’ve ever been

 

[Bruce Wayne]

Just Finished New Game+
I really did enjoy playing it a 2nd Time Around. I only waited like 3 Days to get back at it, I've now Deleted it and will come back to it by the end of the Year. I loved the Shootouts and Crafting for Survival in this Game. Sneaking around with 1 Bottle, 2 Bullets and 3 Enemies lurking in the Shadows.

 

[Doctor Doom]

I gave it a 7. Not enough game play improvements compared to the 1st one, world was pretty much the same, story took a step back with weaker playable characters.

 

[Chris Cool]

10/10 beat it twice and got the plat. One of the few games I've played back to back and first real platinum.

 

[Standing on business]

Game was a damn masterpiece, shyt made you have mixed feelings. Both players were right from their point of view

 

[CrimsonTider]

I gave it a 7. Not enough game play improvements compared to the 1st one, world was pretty much the same, story took a step back with weaker playable characters.

When is the last time you played part 1?

 

[Don Homer]

initial reaction was that it was phenomenal

after a few weeks, it’s still a great game, and a must-play for PS4 owners

Spoiler: If You haven’t already finished the game...

the pacing is good until day 3, then they go back to day 1 to play as Abby for the next 3 days (roughly half the game in real time).

Abbys part is annoying for me bc I don’t care for her character or her story. Idc about the Owen/Mel/Abby love triangle. Idc too much for Yara and Lev. And I just don’t care about the WLF. But abbys story has some of the best gameplay elements and story arcs. The island was dope from start to finish, and her weapons are cool too.

Overall the game is 9/10 for me

 

[Cladyclad]

When Abby when back to Lev home. That shyt is a top 10 moment in gaming for me. That shyt was crazy to me

 

[Methodical]

Voted 9

 

[Jax]

Gave it a 9 but I wanted to give it a 8.8
I'm still salty about some things. Still haven't been able to replay it for the plat.When I will, will probably be a 9.5

 

[5n0man]

Its clear that some people cant get over Joel's death and its effecting their opinion on the game.

Abby was dope, I liked her more than Ellie even tho I maintain that her section felt like a giant detour(as great as that detour was).

Killing joel so early was bold, and probably wasn't the greatest decision, but overall made sense. Either Ellie or Abby should have died at the end, both living was wack.

Still a great game overall.

 

[Deep_Black_Conscious]

Before? A 8/10 or 9/10 because of the ending and feeling like Abby's section was a little forced so you wouldn't completely hate her alongside other issues
Now? 10/10 after understanding what the ending really means and what themes beyond revenge and hate are really behind the game's story
Currently replaying it on the CX for the first time might be biasing my opinion though
Game is amazing production wise, graphics, sound, gameplay sequences, set pieces, combat, etc.
The first playthrough was the best ride of this generation
Honestly the ending ruined the entire game from me in terms of story and experience I didn't know what to think it felt like something was missing
But the experience was too incredible to rate it too harshly however I threw some shade at the game for some time after that ending
That shyt pissed me off what was the point of anything?
Now I understand the ending and story from a different perspective and now I view the story as at least as good as the first game but delivering a different experience and requiring more effort on part of the player than the first time
The effect of the experience was levels above the first game and many other games based off intensity alone

 

[Illuminatos]

8.5/10

Gameplay was fun as hell. That story was buns though.