OROY should be RG3 vs Russell Wilson, not Luck

[thelonious21]

Look I'm not trying to say that Luck sucks, I really believe the opposite. I think he's the real deal, and for the future he is going to be a stud. But his rookie season he's having so far is reminding a lot of Peyton's rookie year. The numbers aren't there(too many ints), but you can see he's going to be good.

That being said, RG3 is the OROY right now, hands down, no question, not even close. What is Luck ends up w/ more picks than TDs? Do you still give him OROY? I understand he's been the guy and has been asked to do more than RG3 and DangeRuss, but I think if either of those QBs were in that situation that they would have done well. I think all 3 of these Qbs are that good, and can do whatever is asked of them.

Yes.. honestly they both would have to do something really bad or something really good to seperate themselves.. right now what luck can hang his hat on is that the team is ABOVE .500 and in the playoff hunt.. RGIII thing is his low low int numbers and great TD ratio..

if either one wins it over ther other its a travesty.. unless as I sais something dramatic happens.

 

[mastermind]

Wilson, Luck vs. same seven opponents - NFC West Blog - ESPN

 

[jetflyinglimousineriding]

 

[Mr swag]

If griffin plays again this season he won easily

 

[...and some waffle fries]

Why are people acting like the Colts wasn't tanking games last yr. They were missing 1 player last yr. Russel or RG3 should get it unless the white privilege works against them.

y'all talkin Luck is asked to do more. Seahawks just put up back to back 50 pt games. What more Russ gotta do???

 

[malbaker86]

Why are people acting like the Colts wasn't tanking games last yr. They were missing 1 player last yr. Russel or RG3 should get it unless the white privilege works against them.

y'all talkin Luck is asked to do more. Seahawks just put up back to back 50 pt games. What more Russ gotta do???

How and why would you tank in a sport that doesn't have guaranteed contracts?

Luck is asked to do more. It's not just that he has a high amount of passing attempts to use as a talking point of him being asked to do more, him and RG3 don't have the defense that Wilson has to be able to game manage. Nothing against Wilson because he's been great as well this year, but RG3 should be the OROY and at this point...does it even matter who wins? Doesn't make whoever doesn't win any less of a QB.

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

People act like the colts defense and the offense has been keeping them in games. Luck has to bring his team back in games this year because of his own turnovers. I guess protecting the football doesn't count with rookies. Wilson is playing on a legit contender. Luck was drafted to be the savior and Wilson was drafted to be a backup so who's been through more adversity? Rg3 had the pressures of being a heisman winner and a team moving up in the draft to get him. People that pick luck only do so for self preservation.

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

I`m actually starting to lean towards Wilson on this shyt.

Seagals are clearly the better all around team though and were before he got there, but he's doing phenomenal stuff.

What a rookie class

 

[Hammer]

wilson has the best stats

 

[South Paw]