OROY should be RG3 vs Russell Wilson, not Luck

[JLova]

Pulling shyt out of your ass.

I havent seen a Seahawks game all year so I don't weigh in on Russell Wilson...feel me...

You obviously haven't watched Redskins or Colts games either.

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

All 3 need to be in the discussion as well as Morris and Martin. Luck is balling breh. That game winning touchdown was stupid nice considering Detroit had them boys dead in the water.

Russ Wilson's game against the Packers

RG3's thanksgiving game

Let us rejoice in the fact we have 3 young highly skilled and high character guys at the quarterback position. This is our generations Elway, Montana, Aikman potentially.

 

[Frump]

I dont understand the overall anti-Luck sentiment on this board.

I think its pretty obvious why

 

[Kenny West]

Co-sign this thread.

Basically the only thing Luck dikkriders can hold on to is the team's record in spite of all the noodle arm deep throws that's been picked off this season.

The MOMENT the Redskins go above .500 (should they do so at all) Luck should be out of the ROY race like he got tossed off the top rope at the Royal Rumble. RGIII is the far better player but the only thing keeping Luck in the arguement is that his team has a winning record. If RG3 brings the Skins up all 3 rookie QBs would have done so.

All that leaves to be compared then are Wilson and Luck's stats, and Wilson and RG3 have much less turnovers.

 

[William Bassington]

The Seahawks did not make the playoffs last year, they were 7-9. I understand Luck is playing very well for the situation, but you can't bring last year into the situation, that doesn't matter.

I think Luck is a close 3rd.

oops my mistake....that was the year before last, but in any case...

but lets be real here...The Seahawks defense is one of the best in the league and they have a running game

Im not an Andrew Luck apologist or anything, but dude has been a one-man show on offense....as a Cowboys fan I can tell you, its hard to be a good QB without a running game..throwing for 4,000 yards as a rookie is impressive...

again, the Colts were the worst team in the league last year...now theyre in the playoff hunt...and they made no huge, glaring moves other than picking Luck

 

[boskey]

You obviously haven't watched Redskins or Colts games either.

I haven't watched much of the Colts. I've seen every single Redskins game, 2 of them in person,my 3rd will be at the end of the month vs. Dallas.

You are talking out of your ass and using your bullshyt PREJUDICES to make a point. RG3 is the furthest thing from a game manager...

 

[I AM WE ARE]

indy has a better overall record
luck is the new manning
the colts coach is dealing with cancer
and oh yeah










HE'S WHITE

 

[Kenny West]

oops my mistake....that was the year before last, but in any case...

but lets be real here...The Seahawks defense is one of the best in the league and they have a running game

Im not an Andrew Luck apologist or anything, but dude has been a one-man show on offense....as a Cowboys fan I can tell you, its hard to be a good QB without a running game..throwing for 4,000 yards as a rookie is impressive...

again, the Colts were the worst team in the league last year...now theyre in the playoff hunt...and they made no huge, glaring moves other than picking Luck

Why do we always have to look at this one way or take several things into prespective when it comes to Luck? bu bu but they were 2-14 last year, bu bu but rookie recivers

Whereas nikkas try to nitpick at Wilson and RG3's heels with strawmen arguements?

I don't give a fukk how bad the Colts were last season. nikka we're in THIS season. Look objectively: Luck throwing out these Stafford/Romo preformances and squeaking out wins against bad teams.

It's RG3 and Wilson right now.

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

Stop it Wilson has played well the past few weeks but most of the year hes been a game manager its assinine to compare stats to Luck whos in a much more wide open offense then Wison

And Wilson has been riding a great defense.

Wilson is very good but Luck & RG3 have been phenomenal

 

[JLova]

I haven't watched much of the Colts. I've seen every single Redskins game, 2 of them in person,my 3rd will be at the end of the month vs. Dallas.

You are talking out of your ass and using your bullshyt PREJUDICES to make a point. RG3 is the furthest thing from a game manager...

*sigh*

Attempts

Luck: 503
Wilson: 317
RG3: 325

Rushing
Redskins: 1st
Seattle: 7th
Indy: 18th

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

I dont understand the overall anti-Luck sentiment on this board.

You don't? I think it's fairly obvious and has been since day one, and it has nothing to do with football

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

How you going to go the game manager route when Russell Wilson averages more yards per attempt?

Because Wilson has done just that for a lot of games, he has a few of them 12-20 for 150 yard games, where Luck has the 31/53 350 yard games.

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

indy has a better overall record
luck is the new manning
the colts coach is dealing with cancer
and oh yeah










HE'S WHITE

Dalton was white and took his team to the playoffs and didn't win ROY

Bad time to pull up that race card.

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

You don't? I think it's fairly obvious and has been since day one, and it has nothing to do with football

Can we skip forward to the accusations of reverse racism?

 

[I AM WE ARE]

Dalton was white and took his team to the playoffs and didn't win ROY

Bad time to pull up that race card.

i'm just saying that history has not been kind besides cam and there was so much debate for dalton to win if you remember

but i think if redskins win their division and he rushes close to 1000 yds and his td to int ratio stays the way it is (17-4) its going to be hard to deny him that award