OROY should be RG3 vs Russell Wilson, not Luck

[South Paw]

Most of these is due to all the hype that these 2 had draft related going 1 and 2, but lets be reality, DangeRuss is having a better rookie year than Luck, and its not even close. Only thing Luck has him on is yards, but hes also throwing the ball 50 times a game. Lets look at the stat comparison.

Wilson
201/317 - 63.4% - 2,344 YDS - 19TD - 8INT - 7.39 YPA - 95.3 QB Rat

Luck
279/503 - 55.5% - 3,596 YDS - 17TD - 16INT - 7.15 YPA - 76.1 QB Rat

So with almost 200 less attempts, Rusell has 2 more tds, better comp %, 8 less picks, better ypa, and way better QB rating

Maybe the competition hasn't been the same, right? Well these 2 have had 7 common opponents this year. (Chicago, Minnesota, Green Bay, Miami, New Endland, Detroit, NYJ) Lets look at those numbers.

Wilson
123/190 - 64.7% - 1,537 YDS - 16TD - 1INT - 8.1 YPA - 115.6 QB Rat

Luck
177/327 - 54.1% - 2,333 YDS - 13TD - 12INT - 7.1 YPA - 74.9 QB Rat

 

[malbaker86]

you really could of posted this in the other thread tho

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

Stop it Wilson has played well the past few weeks but most of the year hes been a game manager its assinine to compare stats to Luck whos in a much more wide open offense then Wison

 

[South Paw]

Stop it Wilson has played well the past few weeks but most of the year hes been a game manager its assinine to compare stats to Luck whos in a much more wide open offense then Wison

Is RG3 also in a wide open offense like Luck?

 

[iamduval]

You guys are getting out of control with this shyt

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

LUCK STANNERY HAS A TEABOW VIBE TO IT...



​

 

[phillycavsfan]

I SAID THIS THE OTHER DAY,
WHEN SOME DUDE HAD THE NERVE TO SAY LUCK & RG3 SHOULD BE CO-ROY.

LUCK STANNERY HAS A TEABOW VIBE TO IT...



​

There's insanity on both sides, apparently.

 

[JLova]

Hard to argue against Wilson and RG3 when you look at the numbers but Luck is asked to do far more than those 2 with less. Both the Skins and Seahawks run very simple offenses (nothing wrong with that) whereas the Colts do not. They throw a lot less than Luck. They also both have dominant running games. Lastly, Luck is told to go out and win games...Russ isn't asked to do that....and neither is RG3 to a lesser extent (at least not as much as Luck).

I think all 3 are great and have no issue with either of them winning, I was just making a case for Luck. Dude is taking a 1 win team to the gotdamn playoffs.

 

[William Bassington]

Luck is def more deserving than Russell...the Seahwaks made the playoffs last year, the Colts had the worst record in the league last year...Luck has been carrying the offense, he has no Marshawn Lynch...he throwing it 40 times a game

 

[jadillac]

I dont understand the overall anti-Luck sentiment on this board.

 

[jdubnyce]

 

[South Paw]

Luck is def more deserving than Russell...the Seahwaks made the playoffs last year, the Colts had the worst record in the league last year...Luck has been carrying the offense, he has no Marshawn Lynch...he throwing it 40 times a game

The Seahawks did not make the playoffs last year, they were 7-9. I understand Luck is playing very well for the situation, but you can't bring last year into the situation, that doesn't matter.

I think Luck is a close 3rd.

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

I dont understand the overall anti-Luck sentiment on this board.

Because it doesn't fit the black athlete-narrative that the board pushes.

 

[South Paw]

Stop it Wilson has played well the past few weeks but most of the year hes been a game manager its assinine to compare stats to Luck whos in a much more wide open offense then Wison

How you going to go the game manager route when Russell Wilson averages more yards per attempt?

 

[boskey]

Lastly, Luck is told to go out and win games...and neither is RG3 to a lesser extent (at least not as much as Luck)

Pulling shyt out of your ass.

RG3 has pretty much been asked to win every single game this year. Literally. Alfred Morris last night was the only time anyone other than RG3 has been asked to step up and make a play on offense. Every 3rd and 4th down has been RG3 making something happen. The kicker gets props too but thats it...

I havent seen a Seahawks game all year so I don't weigh in on Russell Wilson...feel me...