Once and for all Marino > Montana

[Based Lord Zedd]

People will instantly point to rings and it's such a terrible argument.

If this pass isn't dropped all the discussion about Montana being the GOAT is crippled:



The obvious answer will be: "BUT IT WASN'T DROPPED." Which is true but it's not like Montana had any control over whether or not it was, he got lucky. Ranking QBs off an extremely small sample size of games and team accomplishments like SB wins will always be retarded.

I want to hear the argument for Montana over Marino that breaks down their skills/ability and ignores the whole count the rings nonsense. If it's as obvious as people make it out to be, should be an easy question to answer.

 

[Da_Eggman]

this playlist

 

[Absolut]

we really got a dude in here saying montana isnt a top 5 qb because he didnt throw for some arbitrary ass number of yards in a season?

 

[Xtraz2]

Lotta salty Montana haters in here

stats don't mean shyt, any true sports fan knows that

just like Kobe ain't seeing Jordan, Marino ain't seeing Montana

In sports it comes down to can u win when tha pressure is on? All those other throws all season long don't mean shyt

All hail King Montana

 

[Da_Eggman]

Mariano's biggest flaw was being a dolphin....they keep Shula ten years past his prime cuz he was Shula even Marv levy pasted him

 

[wtfyomom]

Marino is the GOAT. Joe Montana just the 80s Brady and Marino the 80s Peyton.

 

[wtfyomom]

Lotta salty Montana haters in here

stats don't mean shyt, any true sports fan knows that

just like Kobe ain't seeing Jordan, Marino ain't seeing Montana

In sports it comes down to can u win when tha pressure is on? All those other throws all season long don't mean shyt

All hail King Montana

spoken like a true idiot. yeah the 16 game season doesnt count, but Im gonna judge someone based on 1-4 games

 

[wtfyomom]

we really got a dude in here saying montana isnt a top 5 qb because he didnt throw for some arbitrary ass number of yards in a season?

I agree but honestly its no more nonsensical than count the rings, actually its a better argument then count the rings, its based in some form of facts and logic at least even though I disagree with it

 

[NYC Rebel]

I'll repeat....the REAL super bowls were the NFC divisional playoffs and NFC Championship games during Joe Montana's era. That's where the best football was played, not the Super Bowl.

Joe's record is completely different playing in the NFC Playoffs during the 80s.

 

[the next guy]

Lol, your delusional kid!

If you really think about it and put your feelings away, Brady, Manning have passed Marino. He's not in my top 3 anymore.

Marino had his shot to win a ring and Montana crushed him. Marino threw 2 picks in that game, you guys can't blame Ray Finkle for that.

brady and manning are not better then marino

 

[Xtraz2]

spoken like a true idiot. yeah the 16 game season doesnt count, but Im gonna judge someone based on 1-4 games

Yup those were tha games that counted, when tha pressures on and you can perform that's what separates tha elite players from tha rest, putting up a bunch of stats is meaningless, it shows u got skill yes, but to be an all around athlete with tha heart if a champion it's about something more important than just raw skill

 

[Reggie]

Montana has the rings so he's gotta be put above Marino. Simple as that.

 

[iPod Raheem 2.0]

Marino is LeBron on the Cavs.

You knew he was a beast. Was my favorite QB growin up

fukk you mean, nikka was the anti-LeBron.

Should've taken his talents away from South Beach, though.

 

[mastermind]

the only three QBs that ever made me jump out of my seat when they tossed the football around are Marino and Rodgers and RG3.

 

[Urahara_Kisuke]

Montana's numbers indicate he was basically Alex Smith with a better supporting cast