Okay but what does Chief Judd’s death have to do with anything Lindelof might have wanted to do 15 years ago when a
Watchmen TV series wasn’t even a twinkle in his eye? Well back in 2004 Lindelof was hard at work with
J.J. Abrams sketching out the show that would launch him into the TV stratosphere:
Lost. Their plan to dazzle audiences was to cast a famous movie actor (back before famous movie actors doing TV shows was de rigueur) as the show’s ostensible lead and then bump him off in the pilot. The actor in question was
Michael Keaton and he would play Dr. Jack Shephard, the kind of identifiable hero TV audiences knew to look out for. But the
real star of the show and leader of the plane crash survivors on that mysterious island would be Kate Austen played by then-newcomer
Evangeline Lilly.
Lindelof has, diplomatically, never
explicitly said why the network turned down this pitch prompting Keaton—
who didn’t want to make an entire TV show—to drop out and
Matthew Fox to pick up the mantle as the show’s leading man. But in a 2015
essay, former
Lost writer
Javier Grillo-Marxuach said bluntly that the reason Abrams and Lindelof couldn’t get away with it was “the sad reality of American network television in 2004 was that shows needed competent, easily identifiable main characters with abilities that undeniably spoke to their leadership and heroism: and that was, most of the time, a handsome white guy with an advanced degree in criminology, law, or medicine…and an absurdly tragic backstory.”
Grillo-Marxuach continued, “When J.J. and Damon returned from their first network notes session with a slightly bemused expression, I asked how the notes session went. I was not shocked when Damon shrugged with a not inconsiderable amount of contempt for his unimaginative corporate overlords and reported that, ‘We can’t kill the white guy.’” In a recent
podcast interview, Lindelof said, “I agree with everything [Grillo-Marxuach] wrote. I would corroborate his account as being one thousand percent authentic. This is not a man who tells lies.”